Higher education honors programs have traditionally been designed to give high-achieving students a chance to push themselves further and deeper academically at the collegiate level, but in today’s age of equity, one university aims to turn the idea on its head.
San Jose State University is working to launch what has been temporarily dubbed the “(un) Honors College” as scholars work to design a model that best fits their vision.
The effort aims to attract the “region’s BIPOC communities,” stated senior vice president for academic affairs Vincent Del Casino when he announced the undertaking last September.
BIPOC stands for Black, Indigenous, People of Color.
The large public university nestled in California’s Silicon Valley already offers various traditional honors programs.
The new program would not replace them, Del Casino stated, but instead push “past historical conversations about honors education and toward a dialogue about how we create radical, new learning spaces responsive to and inspired by the complex and intersectional diversity of our local communities and our students.”
“Maybe what we end up with doesn’t have the word ‘honors’ in it at all.”
The underpinning idea is that the (Un) Honors College would not consist of traditional high-GPA students, but rather “marginalized populations,” said professors who are developing the program in a task force presentation in May 2021 posted on YouTube.
The scholars talked of the program consisting of very small class sizes, peer mentoring, hands-on learning opportunities, and a hyper-focus on an interdisciplinary education.
One big priority the “(un) Honors College” will advance is “equity,” several professors said during the presentation.
For example, biology Professor Walter Adams, a faculty task force member focused on admissions, said “we need equity every step of the way through this process.”
“Admissions criteria that work against diversity and equity is a bad idea,” he said during the May presentation.
In June, Adams presented a possible solution to that end: an “equity application.” It would award applicants points over how much inequity they’ve faced based on factors such as gender, race and sexual orientation.
The idea was ultimately scrapped because it would run afoul of a California law that bans public universities from considering race in admissions.
Elizabeth Weiss, a professor in the anthropology department at San Jose State who is not a member of the task force developing the program, said in an interview with The College Fix that the budding (un) Honors College aims to serve a specific purpose.
“They want students of color, they want students who don’t have the good GPAs, who don’t do well on SATs and so forth,” Weiss said.
“Part of this is creating a system for students who are not doing well,” she said. “In honors programs, classes are smaller, teachers have a lighter load. It’s giving resources at the expense of the regular students.”
Del Casino has said the task force will present some specific recommendations on how to implement the concept to the wider campus community this fall.
The above comes from an Aug. 10 story on the College Fix.
Truth in labeling should be upfront and call this a remedial program, perhaps an ‘ honoring program”. It actually dishonors the students just like handing out trophies to every team member in high school sports diminishes the real winners’ excellence. And enriches the sports trophy business
it’s positively de-evolutionary. This is a classic example of the soft prejudice of low expectation.
I have seen so many young people go to college who had no business going to college. It is free or almost free with scholarships and there are extra incentives for students with grade averages of C+ or less.
Then the colleges have to put in remedial classes. The kids do poorly. They drop out. They could have been in a trade school or an apprenticeship or just getting job and life experience.
College isn’t for everyone.
You’re right, college isn’t for everyone and that’s why there are trade schools.
If you’ve hired a plumber or electrician lately you know blue collar careers are well paying.
i gots me a phd
in illiteracy
phd = pheel happy degree
A.k.a. GED.
Why do they even bother with the charade of education anymore? Just mail everyone a college degree in the field of their choice upon request.
Hymie:
don’t besmirch the good name
of GED holders by this uncharitable comparison
as the immortal character Lance
said in the equally immortal movie
“Orange County”
“Hey, I didn’t go to college – and I’m kick-ass!”
The only thing these people want to “honor” is themselves.
The world and inhabitants thereof have gone crazy. Live with it and shut up if you don’t have the guts to fight it.
The left continues its pro-slavery stance as it always has. Pathetic and disgusting to push the position that color of skin makes you stupid or less capable. Disgusting. Thank you God my black grandson has been spared this plantation mentality.
This is absolutely stupid. Bring the students up to a higher standard…do not lower the standards so they are not challenged and learn nothing valuable.
Great news.
I can be this stupid on my own.
Saves me the trouble & expense of going to college.
I agree that this is blatant racism with a new name, but then … My biracial grandchildren are doing just fine; great grades in college prep in high school, one with a BA in 31/2 years, a second a sophomore with straight As and Bs. They don’t need this program. But, and it is a big but, they live in an upper-middle-class area with great schools and other programs. They don’t live in ghettos, or areas with poor schools, high levels of poverty that result in poor nutrition. They had books at home that their college grad parents could read to them. They had lots of advantages. There are millions of kids who need some equity help so that they can get on the road to a better life. The difficulty is getting it to them without diminishing the culture of meritocracy.