“Hope you are well. Thank you again for meeting with us last week, we were very pleased to hear about the actions that HHS is taking on this issue. I wanted to check in on HHS & DMHC progress, including where you are in the timeline to finding a solution in 4-6 weeks? Is there anything further that our folks can provide as far as legal analysis or documents? Would it be possible to set up a recurring call over the next couple of week for us to chat? I know we said that you and I would keep in touch on how things are going and the folks who participated in the meeting are getting anxious for word on the issue and will continue want updates as things progress.”
This may seem like yet another boring Washington Beltway email full of alphabet soup. But looks can be deceiving. That seemingly banal email is clear evidence of a troubling collaboration between a state government agency and strident abortion supporters. It also raises troubling questions about who is actually driving public policies directly affecting churches and other explicitly religious entities.
The above quote was an excerpt of an email uncovered during the discovery phase of a 2015 lawsuit filed by Alliance Defending Freedom. The lawsuit was filed by ADF on behalf of its California clients: Calvary Chapel Chino Hills in Chino, The Shepherd of the Hills Church in Porter Ranch, and Foothill Church in Glendora.
Who was the author of the email above, the one seemingly calling the shots? A legislative advocate working for Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California.
And who is the other party in this email chain, the DMHC? The California Department of Managed Health Care.
Yes, you read that right. The state government and Planned Parenthood were literally plotting over email how to force churches to cover abortion procedures for women employed by churches. Planned Parenthood claims to speak for these women, but as Lisa Amann (of Skyline Wesleyan Church in San Diego) once pointed out, Planned Parenthood obviously doesn’t speak for the female employees of these churches who are suing. (Skyline was involved in a separate lawsuit against the DMHC over the same issue. All four churches are ADF clients.)
This legal case began as Foothill Church, Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, and Shepherd of the Hills Church v. Michelle Rouillard. Ms. Rouillard was the Director of DMHC at the time. Prior to formally filing the lawsuit, ADF had “filed formal complaints with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services against DMHC regarding California’s mandate and its violation of federal conscience law. Those came on the heels of a complaint filed directly with DMHC, which responded by affirming its decision to force all plans to cover all abortions without any explanation as to how that decision squares with the Constitution and contrasting federal law….”
The above comes from an August 29 posting on the Washington Stand.
Everyone who votes for Democrats is guilty of grave evil. No one can plead ignorance about the Democrats enacting evil such as this.
Calvary Chapel in Chino Hills is one of the leading organizations opposing Proposition One. Real Impact is a ministry of that (single) church. Along with California Family Council and Capitol Resource Institute, they’re mobilizing our evangelical sisters and brothers in this fall’s fight for life. All Christians and people of good will are in this together to protect babies and mothers from the violence of abortion. I’ve heard that some Catholics are having difficulty getting information and resources from their parishes. If you are, you may want to consider checking out what they offer. (This is clearly a matter where, as Vatican II teaches, we should be working together with our separated brothers and sisters for the good of all.) May God bless all working to protect human life. Below is what Calvary Chapel Chino Hills is doing:
Sheperd of the Hills
does a lot of good work
in the San Fernando Valley.