Thank god for non-binary and the absolute illogic and lunacy of it all. It has finally revealed what parents have known all along — this transgender youth thing is a made up, cultish quasi-religion, not an innate, immutable feeling.
If non-binary surgery is a thing (ie, in support of your non-binary gender identity, take wrong sex hormones in “regular” or “micro” doses, amputate your breasts, remove your nipples, create a “smooth” genital area — essentially de-sex your sexed body), then no longer does the narrative of “I have a female brain in a male body” or vice versa make any sense.
If trans means that:
- Your soul is gendered and its identity can match or not match your physical body.
- If it doesn’t match, this is an intolerable situation that causes great distress.
- You will want to kill yourself if you can’t, through drugs, 3rd party pronouns, and surgeries, transform yourself into the opposite sex and/or induce an endocrine disorder to go through the “right” puberty if you are still a youngster.
- Your gender identity is your “true self” and everyone in the world is morally obligated to affirm and assist you right away in having the body that you want or they will have your blood on their hands and you are a transphobe.
Then, in that case, what does that make non-binary? There is no such thing as an unsexed human body that the gender identity of non-binary can match—the whole concept behind this is patently ludicrous, since there is no such thing in humans as a 3rd sex (or a “no sex?). So, if non-binaries cannot be said to be born in the wrong body, since there isn’t a “right” body alternative for them, the idea that trans is a medical necessity, rather than a set of drug and cosmetic procedures to alter your body to match some idea of inner self, fails to hold water.
It becomes obviously what it was all along — transgender and it’s non-binary child are no different from Octomom who spent years of plastic surgery in pursuit of looking like Angelina Jolie. It becomes clear that trans-racialism and trans-species-ism, and body identity integrity disorder, where you have an overwhelming desire to be an amputee, are one and the same. Disorders of the self, psychological issues, for which hasty medicalization is clearly inappropriate, for anyone, much less for vulnerable teens.
I, for one, am thankful for the explosion in non-binary-ism. It has made the whole trans thing jump the shark. An absurdity on top of an absurdity that will topple the whole tower of absurdity, pain and suffering down upon itself in a heap of nonsensical rubbish. Even our trans-identified kids can’t fail to see, eventually, how stupid non-binary medicine is. Let’s hope that the grownups in the room see it even sooner.
From a March 21 posting by Parents with Inconvenient Truths about Trans.
It is so sad to me that some conservatives demand that parents have a right to regulate what their children are taught when it comes to some things, but when it comes to other things, these same parents want to claim to be the adults in the room and regulate what the children of other parents are taught.
As someone who rejects the natural moral law your opinion is par for that course. Morally inverted
Peace be with you bohemond!
There will no peace YFC, when lies are taught as truth and the Divine Truth is considered Hate.
What’s sad, rather, is that so many people accept the lies of LGBT ideology and want those lies taught to children. Lies should never be taught to children.
You seem to be on the side of lies. You know who the father of lies is, don’t you? That puts you on his side.
Honest question: What is LGBT ideology?
It’s the false view that heterosexuality is not normative for human beings nor for the good of the social order, therefore social institutions and laws should recognize and affirm the L, the G, the B and the T as being on par with heterosexuality, with no preference implied nor given to any form of sexual identity, expression, relationship or activity.
Bullseye…here’s another way of putting it . the LGBT ideology is the overthrow of the Social Order commanded by the Christ the King…
“What is LGBT ideology?” It is primarily a system of thought that seeks to legitimize sexual deviance/dysphoria in all or most of its forms. This amounts to acceptance of any sexual conduct between consenting adults but has grown to the influencing of children in sexual deviance/dysphoria, destroying their innocence. I’m sure YFC you can add to this definition, and I will appreciate your contribution
Ideology are ideas and ideals.
Can’t tell you what LGBTQ ideology is.
I can tell you what Catholic ideology is. It is the ideas and ideals taught by the Catholic Church.
Marriage is between one man and one woman, lifelong and exclusive. Sex is reserved for marriage. Sex must remain open to life. God is the author of life. All human life is sacred. Human life is to be protected and honored.
The ideas and ideals taught by the Catholic Church on faith and morals are to be obeyed. They are from God the Creator, Redeemer and Sanctifier.
Sorry. I don’t feed trolls.
If you don’t feed them they might make a pattie out of you
YFC— You post on a Catholic site but always with a view adverse to Church teaching, either directly or by false equivalencies. You lead with your chin. Don’t be offended (even if covered-up by false piety) when others smack it.
Consequences: Actually I take positions that are adverse to people on this site who don’t know what the Church teaches, or at least they don’t post what the Church teaches. The Church teaches nothing about so called LGBT ideology and I honestly dont even know what that even means. I suspect you don’t. I suspect none of you do, because it’s not a term the Church uses and people don’t live their lives out of an ideology but out of the reality of their lives. What exactly IS LGBT ideology and where has the Church spoken about it?
YFC, you are just being dishonest. You are trying to pretend that you are intellectual when you are really just picking on others.
“The Church teaches nothing about so called LGBT ideology and I honestly don’t even know what that even means.” This is the most disingenuous comment I have ever read, YFC. I gave you a good head start– now finish it. You can do it.
Here’s what I think. I don’t think objective observers would understand an ideology associated with LGBT anything. I don’t think most LGBT people even think about the things you all put in there. Ideology is primarily about economics and politics. The Church does not teach anything at all about LGBT ideology. I think you all use it as a grab bag for anything you don’t personally like about LGBT orientations and gloss over or even sometimes disregard what the Church actually says.
That is not to say that the Church teaches that homosexuality is not disordered, or that homosexual activity is not sinful, or that homosexual couples can be sacramentally married. Clearly, it does. But it also teaches that homosexual people are to be treated with respect and dignity, viewed compassionately for their state in life, and that they should not be subject to violence or unjust discrimination. It does not teach that gay people should be imprisoned, that they should be denied the basics of living a dignified life (housing, gainful employment, enjoy basic human freedoms like the freedoms of speech and religion, form social bonds with others, and access to affordable health care). It doesn’t teach that homosexual people don’t exist. Or that homosexual people should be shamed. Or that homosexual people should be re-oriented to become straight. Or that homosexual people should be silenced. It doesn’t even teach that same sex couples cannot forge affective relationships for their own mutual support.
In fact, the catechism spends more words describing how others are to treat homosexuals than it does prohibiting homosexual sex and sacramental marriage. Yet most of you forget that almost all of the time, at least those of you who comment.
I’d be happy to treat people with LGBT disorders respectfully and I do. But when they shout GAY GAY GAY GAY GAY all the time and try to make the schools teach GAY GAY GAY GAY instead of what schools should be teaching, and when in the church they try to gay up the liturgy and try to get the church to change its teachings about marriage and sex or imply that they are right and the church is wrong, it wears thin and I push back. Ain’t nothing wrong with pushing back, either. Gays are welcome as long as they know their place. They’ll be respected as long as they keep to their place, which includes not telling everyone how gay they are or how proud they are and no gay public displays of affection. Nobody is interested. Just keep it to yourself and things will go a lot better for them in the church.
The dudes at the gay parish in the Castro in San Francisco gay it up at the sign of peace. Nobody wants to see that.
Right, gays should “know their place”. Exactly the words used in the fifties to keep black people at the back of the bus and out of the lunch counters.
YFC, you lied or distorted when someone posted the link to the Catholic Education document about gender theory. You said the words trans ideology or LGBT ideology were not in the document.
The word ideology is in there 6 times.
You are a college professor. You know full well how to use a dictionary. Making the false claim that ideology only has to do with economics and politics is ridiculous.
You are a married gay man. You know you are not supposed to be Catholic and in a same sex marriage or in a civil marriage. So that is dishonest.
Stop hiding behind the catechism when you don’t even obey it.
What people object to in your posts is your dishonesty.
Wait what? He’s gay married? Is that true? I don’t want to read another thing he says.
CCComment: Nothing I said was a lie, not a single thing.
I didn’t search the document for “ideology”, I searched the document for “trans ideology” and “LGBT ideology”, neither of which are found in the document.
I do know how to use a dictionary. Here is what comes up in the online dictionary my browser pulls up: “noun: ideology; plural noun: ideologies 1. a system of ideas and ideals, especially one which forms the basis of economic or political theory and policy.
“the ideology of democracy”” In fact, I consulted that dictionary before I wrote my post on 3/23, hence my post included these words which you say are a lie: “Ideology is primarily about economics and politics.” Its fine if you don’t like my phraseology, but that doesn’t make me a liar.
Besides I never said I didn’t know what the word “ideology” means. I said I didn’t know what the “LGBT ideology” means.
CCComment: The rest of your response doesn’t address any lie, though I’d correct you that I am not a college professor, lest you call me a liar for not correcting you.
I use the Catechism to demonstrate what the Church actually teaches, in opposition to what most others here THINK it teaches. I don’t hide behind it, I raise it up.
And you are dishonest again: I did not say that you lied. Did I?
Did you retire?
CCComment I didn’t say you said I lied, did I? So how exactly was I dishonest this time?
YFC, maybe you’d be better off if you didn’t “suspect” so much. Being so suspicious is detrimental to mental health; it places you on the paranoid end of the spectrum.
YFC, until fairly recently homosexuality was called “the love that dare not speak its name”. Now it won’t shut up. A lot of Catholics are tired of those who try to plant more and more pansies in the Church garden.
If I send my child to, say, a pottery spinning class, I expect him to come home with a coffee cup or a plate, not a kiln fired and glazed sharpened weapon. I get to say that anyone teaching my child does not get to weaponize pottery.
If I send my child to elementary school, I expect him to learn to read and to math and think critically, not be indoctrinated in an incoherent irrational ideology or be punished..and I get to say so.
The arguments you give are the garden variety false comparisons and contradictions and are studies in logical fallacies that characterize the progressive narrative and the current educational zeitgeist.
I disagree that it will topple the tower. I think it will expand it and there will be something after it.
It may become prominent and even dominant.
It is going to have a huge impact in terms of freeing people from self-imposed stereotypes and learned behavior.
It actually could have a positive impact. God will bring good from it.
It could lead to greater chastity, better sexual values, better modesty.
Hooray! Governor DeSantis, future president of the United States, signed a declaration stripping Will Thomas of his win in the NCAA women’s championship and giving first place to the female swimmer with the fastest time in the event.
Let’s push back against the LGBT insanity. DeSantis can ride such a wave all the way to the White House because many Americans are fed up and just want someone to speak loudly against and stand up to the LGBT nonsense that is ruining our country and our children.
The government is now declaring who wins a college swim meet?
Why not? The government declared that two men can marry each other. Anything goes.
Some people only object to the totalitarianism that they do not agree with.
I do not agree with that.
Is every government declaration an act of “totalitarianism”?
Where are the moms and dads to protect these children from the onslaught of lies? God have mercy on us all.
“Ideology is primarily about economics and politics” according to YFC, March 23, 2022 at 11:40 am. Again YFC, you are disingenuous. An ideology can be any firm set of beliefs, with the sense that they are adhered to without question, I think the post of “no preference from March 22 said it best: “It’s the false view that heterosexuality is not normative for human beings nor for the good of the social order, therefore social institutions and laws should recognize and affirm the L, the G, the B and the T as being on par with heterosexuality, with no preference implied nor given to any form of sexual identity, expression, relationship or activity.” This ideology runs counter to and is highly destructive of the Natural/Moral Law upon which Judeo/Christian ethic is based. An entirely separate issue is your assertion that since reparative therapy is not in the Catechism, that therefore it be banned. You don’t say that explicitly, but your views on this are well known. Then what do you say for those for whom this therapy has worked?
dis crazy surgery:
“it was the most unkindest cut of all.”
an ideology that is given the general name ‘gender theory’, which “denies the difference and
reciprocity in nature of a man and a woman and envisages a society without sexual differences, thereby eliminating the anthropological basis of
the family. This ideology leads to educational programmes and legislative
enactments that promote a personal identity and emotional intimacy radically separated from the biological difference between male and female.
Consequently, human identity becomes the choice of the individual, one
which can also change over time”
While the ideologies of gender claim to respond, as Pope Francis
has indicated, “to what are at times understandable aspirations”, they also
seek “to assert themselves as absolute and unquestionable, even dictating
how children should be raised”, and thus preclude dialogue.
This ideology inspires educational programmes and legislative trends
that promote ideas of personal identity and affective intimacy that make
a radical break with the actual biological difference between male and female.
Human identity is consigned to the individual’s choice, which can also
change in time. These ideas are the expression of a widespread way of
thinking and acting in today’s culture that confuses “genuine freedom
with the idea that each individual can act arbitrarily as if there were no
truths, values and principles to provide guidance, and everything were
possible and permissible”.
I actually gave the dictionary definition of an ideology before, which had been the basis of my statement about economics or politics, but CCD edited it out of my comment. But here it is again:
Learn to pronounce
noun: ideology; plural noun: ideologies
a system of ideas and ideals, especially one which forms the basis of economic or political theory and policy.
“the ideology of democracy” ”
There is a second definition but it is an archaic usage.
The LBGT ideology is political YFC. It’s a Marxist subset just like feminism made up to attack God through humanity since Satan can’t attack God directly. You may not be aware but the first known “Gay parade” and the first “feminist parade” took place in 1906 or 1907 in Moscow to demoralize the people and prepare for the Bolshevik revolution. Poor souls have bought the atheist lies that attacks God through His creation of man and the other attacks the Blessed Virgin Mary. Also, though I agree ‘God have mercy on us all’ someone is using my moniker as I did not post on this article until now.
Additionally as we see through the course of human history we are moving on from normalizing trans to pedophilia, the step after that is beastie little and concludes with cannibalism. Things are declining so rapidly these ideologies are stepping all over each other time wise, sped along by the internet I suppose. An “intellectual better” in Sweden has already suggested some months ago that we should consider cannibalism for sustainability.
Granny, you need new glasses if you saw that through the course of human history.
Once you see it YFC you can’t unsee it. Anyone with eyes to see and ears to hear can track human behavior through the course of history. There are 3 excuses I can think of which deny it. 1.ignorance of the history humanity. 2. Blindness to the course of human civilizations 3. Those who believe we just haven’t done it right yet and if we do we can bring about utopia, through mans efforts alone we can have heaven on earth. It’s a lie straight from the pit of hell, where according to the blessed mother, ‘many souls go because they have no one to pray for them.’ If we put our efforts into that effort we might see a period of peace. Instead we do the same thing over and over and over.
Just don’t respond to YFC. It’s a waste of your precious time. YFC is anything but, yet thrives on getting a reaction from unsuspecting and innocent souls and will jerk around anyone who happen to come across this site.