The following comes from a May 6 story in the Los Angeles Times.
In a letter to affiliated physicians and staff, Hoag Hospital in Newport Beach announced that elective abortions will no longer be performed at the hospital because of the low number of procedures done annually.
The decision was based on a review of clinical services performed at the facility that began last fall.
Hoag Chief Executive and President Robert Braithwaite said the hospital places a high value on the level of care it provides, and that there is a direct correlation between quality of care and the number of procedures performed. Braithwaite said elective abortions are seldom performed in hospitals partly because of the expense and also because of the less private or intimate setting.
Hoag provided about 100 abortions a year, compared with 6,000 births and 10,000 mammograms, Braithwaite said.
“The bottom line is to provide high-quality healthcare to this community,” he said.
The decision does not affect the dispensing of emergency contraception following rape or sexual assault, emergency services for women who experience complications from pregnancy termination at other facilities, or management of ectopic or other pregnancy complications, according to the letter sent out to physicians dated May 1.
The review of services was prompted by the hospital’s partnership with St. Joseph Health, a Roman Catholic-affiliated institution, although Braithwaite said at no point did St. Joseph pressure the board to change its policy on elective abortions. He pointed to other procedures still performed at Hoag, including tubal ligation, which are typically not provided by Catholic healthcare providers.
Hospital officials emphasized that patient-physician relationships wouldn’t change and that Hoag-affiliated doctors could still perform abortions, just not at Hoag.
Physicians had mixed reactions to the announcement, according to Dr. Allyson Brooks, the executive medical director for Hoag’s Women’s Health Institute.
“We consider ourselves a center of excellence … and have provided great care, so it’s not unusual for our OB/GYN staff to feel like something went away,” Brooks said.
She said that on an individual basis, many physicians understood the change because so few elective abortions were performed at Hoag. Some doctors were worried that other factors played a part in the decision, Brooks said, but she denied this.
Brooks said there would not be a lack of access to the service since there are many other nearby academic and outpatient centers where elective abortions are performed, including UC Irvine, Planned Parenthood and Family Planning Associates Medical Group.
The elimination of elective abortions isn’t the first time the hospital has gotten rid of a program, Braithwaite said. About five years ago, the hospital decided to eliminate in-patient pediatric care because it felt those patients were best served by the Children’s Hospital of Orange County.
To read original story, click here.
To read Feb. 28 release announcement of Hoag and St. Joseph partnership, click here.
Probably I am simple minded, but if there is a category called “elective abortions”, it is logical to assume that there is a category called “non-elective abortions”. Presumably these are abortions that MDs advise a mother to have because perhaps a fetal abnormality is discovered. My question: Can we assume then that non-elective abortions will be performed at Hoag, a hospital now in partnership with the Catholic St. Joseph Health system? What about tubal ligations, contraception and “management of ectopic or other pregnancy complications”? Someone is not coming clean on what this all means. Seems to me that abortions – selective abortions – will still be performed at Hoag, under the auspices of a Catholic Health system. Am I correct?
Just to be sure that St. Joseph Health is Catholic, I looked at their website. Sure enough, there were 5 nuns on the Board of Trustees. Also on the Board was Edward Dolejsi, Executive Director of the California Catholic Conference of Bishops. Is he in agreement that St. Joseph can perform abortions?
What should we make of all this?
Maria, I think that you questions are reasonable. As to the non-elective abortion question, I imagine that in medical speech a non-elective abortion would refer to a miscarriage. In Spanish this would be referred to as “un aborto natural”. As to your question about a Catholic Health Organization offering contraceptives and sterilization’s in some of its hospitals, I would say that there is already precedence for this when Catholic Health Care West (now I believe called Dignity) offered these services in those hospitals they purchased which were previously not Catholic. I believe that there was an outcry about this at the time. I do not have any knowledge of St. Joseph’s Health”s position on this.
Marie,
Some time ago, one CRCOA’s Board did the research and found that a disgusting number of “doctors” who perform abortions had hospital rights at both St. Joseph’s and St. Jude’s, and both were and are under the heterodox Sisters of St. Joseph of Orange!
God bless, yours in Their Hearts,
Kenneth M. Fisher