The following comes from an July 31 Buzzfeed article by Azeen Ghorayshi and Cora Lewis:
In California, women who donate their eggs to infertile couples are paid — and sometimes, paid lavishly. Not so if they want to donate their eggs to science.
But a bill headed to the California state senate on Monday could change that. Sponsored by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), the leading body for the fertility industry, AB 2531 would overturn a 2006 law barring researchers from paying women.
The bill is pitting some scientists who want to use the eggs for research against women’s health advocates, who say it would incentivize poor women to take unnecessary health risks.
Adding urgency to the issue, many scientists are eager for more eggs to study cloning, stem cells, and fertility in a state that invests more in biomedical research than any other.
“A number of our members at some of California’s very fine research institutions tell us that they have a hard time finding women to donate eggs for research purposes because compensation is not allowed,” Tipton said.
Some labor activists are also in favor of the bill, as it would let more women be paid for the work of enduring the painful and potentially risky procedure.
But opponents say that financially incentivizing women to donate could push them to make risky decisions they otherwise wouldn’t. The long-term health effects of repeated egg donation remain unknown, they say. So incentivizing women to go through the invasive, 10-day procedure for scientific research could end up doing more harm than good.
The California Catholic Conference needs to speak out loudly and boldly against AB 2531. Every Bishop in the State of California should do all in his power to encourage their flocks to contact their representatives in the Assembly to express their total disagreement with this piece of legislation. The donation of eggs or sperm, whether for free or for money is completely immoral. In “Donum Vitae” issued in 1987 by the Cong. for the Doctrine of the Faith, approved by Pope John Paul II, the Church has already spoken out against this practice.
Let’s see.
It will be interesting to see whether the bishops take a stance against this legislation which, as you point out, has no room for ambiguity regarding its morality.
Meanwhile the bishops took a stance against capital punishment, which Catholics are able to support in good conscience as an option for the administration of justice.
So if the bishops oppose something that Catholics may support while being silent about something that Catholics must oppose, it will reveal quite a lot about their poor judgment and their misplaced priorities regarding political matters.
Oh beautiful, golden state of California, why are you the ‘petri dish’ of unholy activities? A ‘testing site’ for the un-natural? The epicenter’ of the return of Sodom & Gomorrah (aka San Francisco). It was not always that way. Pray that good people take back the Sacred in the spiritual war raging on your soil. Go to this site, by Cardinal Burke, @ http://www.holyleague.com/ AND as the bible says many times, Be Not Afraid but PRAY for deliverance. God save us from every evil.
This should be AGAINST THE LAW, universally! God made men and women to bring forth children in Holy Matrimony! To sell your future sons and daughters is SATANIC!!