The parents of a Jesuit High School student have filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the suburban Sacramento institution, alleging that their son’s objections to teaching critical race theory led to him being labeled a “bigot” and his forced withdrawal from school.
The lawsuit, filed late Thursday in federal court in Sacramento, identifies the student only as “A.P.,” a 17-year-old Mexican-American student with attention deficit hyperactivity syndrome and dyslexia.
The suit says the dispute began after a June 23 letter signed by five students was distributed at the school advocating for “fundamental changes in various aspects of the school’s curriculum, policies and culture,” including the teaching of critical race theory.
“Teaching CRT has been banned outright in a number of states, and anti-CRT legislation is pending in other state across the country,” the suit says, labeling the decades-old teaching subject “highly controversial.”
“The letter was read in classes, distributed to the student body, and students were asked to add their signatures to the letter in a show of support,” the lawsuit says. It was not distributed to parents.
“Students were asked in class what they thought of the June 23 Letter, and A.P. shot off saying he thought it was ‘retarded.’ The teacher quickly reminded A.P. that ‘we are careful with our words.’ Nothing else was said, and no discipline was imposed.”
The suit concedes that the student’s use of the term was “inappropriate,” but says it was a “slang to express criticism of the letter,” not an attack on someone with “intellectual disability.”
Weeks later, a Jesuit dean, LaRoddric Theodule, confronted A.P. and told him another student had accused him of using a racial slur for an African American. The student said he also called another student a homosexual slur, the suit says.
“Initially, A.P. was uncertain what Dean Theodule was talking about, but when he realized it was the event two weeks prior and had a moment to think about it, he acknowledged that he another student had jokingly called each other” (a gay slur), the suit says. “(The other student was ordered to write a letter of apology to the coach, and the matter was dropped.)
“When asked about the racial slur, A.P. was adamant that he had never directed the term at or used it to refer to a person.”
Despite that, A.P. was told not to attend classes on May 5 and a week later appeared before a disciplinary board, the suit says.
“It was conducted via zoom and consisted of A.P. being interrogated non-stop for an hour and 20 minutes by three school administrators, and eventually being reduced to tears,” the suit says. “He admitted and apologized profusely for using the term ‘fag,’ even as a joke with his friend.
“He again adamantly denied directing the (slur) at or using it to refer to a person. Withstanding a hostile cross-examination by multiple persons for that long would be a challenge for most resilient adults to manage; subjecting a teenager with ADHD and dyslexia to such an ordeal was abusive and discriminatory.”
The suit, filed by San Francisco attorney Elizabeth Thompson, claims the principal became angry during the session, that Wood “planted his fists on the table, stared into the camera and declaimed: ‘Your sin is racism. You are a racist and a bigot!’
The next day, the principal called A.P.’s parents and told them their son “would not be allowed to continue attending JHS” and would have his transcript given a notation of “withdrawn – discipline.”
The suit says A.P’s treatment by Jesuit is “endangering his college prospects” and has caused “extreme and enduring emotional distress” that has led to A.P. seeking counseling.
The above comes from a July 30 story by The Sacramento Bee.
and people pay big bucks for
this indoctrination in insanity???
for the greater glory of the gulag
Dean Theodule worked at Archbishop Mitty, overlapping with current “woke” abortion promoting President Latanya, there a serious problem with Catholic schools in Northern California. The weak Bishops Oscar and Jaime really need to get it together and protect the children’s souls.
It is relevant in this case to mention that Dean Rod Theodule is black. So there would have been racial overtones in the black dean’s confrontation of the Latino student over charges of using a racial slur directed against blacks and the student’s unfavorable opinion of CRT. Rod Theodule also used to work at Bellarmine Prep in San Jose, another Jesuit high school.
No kidding he is in counseling.
I don’t know what they were teaching but CRT is not the issue here.
False accusation. Harassment. Bullying
When my kids were in Catholic school, there was one school where the administrator bullied our child right in front of us during the interview.
i was relieved when he was not accepted. My spouse was so enamored of the school’s reputation and upper crust milieu that he could not even see the abuse.
One of the first questions was “have you been able to find a house to buy here?” Expensive area.
Trust me, nobody bringing these brouhahas over critical race theory even knows what it means. What it means for Republican and far right legal groups for their next fundraising rallying cry. The overlords have told you to watch out for this, and riled you up for this fight. It’s not being taught in secondary schools, and it has been around as an academic theory for decades.
CRT is anti white racism, why can you not see that and why blast those who do?
CRT is scapegoating the elitist way cloaked in pseudo intellectual terms, but the end result is white people are inherently evil, blacks eternal victims…
Yes, but, what they mean by critical race theory is teaching kids wrong. I just heard that the reason the second amendment was put into the Constitution was so that white people could own guns to put down slave uprisings. Not correct.
That attitude is why so many conservatives find elite, Democrat, liberal smug condescension abhorrent. It is being taught in high schools. CRT is Marxist social poison.
Nobody but you and the woke know what CRT means?
I find that very difficult to believe. But I’d better believe it or someone will work hard to cancel me, isn’t that correct?
“Don’t turn around the Kommissar’s in town”.
Have you thought about studying some critica Christian theology?
I have about 15 graduate credits in theology and pastoral ministry. Zero in critical race theory.
I would have been disappointed if this happened at a Catholic high school. Fortunately it didn’t. This is a Jesuit school.
The best comment here.
Francis, is that you giving a thumbs down to my comment? Take notice that 93% of the thumbs are pointing up.
Do you really think Pope Francis reads this website or the comments? Sheesh.
No of course I don’t think he has the time to read all the comments on here, just mine. Sorry you didn’t know.
Another example of why homeschooling is becoming parents’ best option for educating their children.
What else to expect? It’s a Jesuit institution. St. Francis Xavier must be rolling in his grave.
Let me hazard a guess. No one who commented about CRT has read the textbooks about it, know the authors, or have studied it in depth. I haven’t either and I hope my guess is wrong. So, if we haven’t read the texts, studied the concept, etc. how are we qualified to call it Marxist, communist, anti-white, etc? As someone who has studied and taught US history. I can tell you that the textbooks used in most schools don’t do a good job of explaining institutional racism. When institutional racism is mentioned, too many people get all worked up because they assume they, personally, are being accused of being racist, which isn’t true for most of us. What is true, is that from the late 1600s until today, our system has had, and has built-in barriers to equality. We should be willing to recognize them. Now, however, we must find a better way to teach the subject in our schools. Let’s start with why Blacks were not counted as whole people in our Constitution, or why they were not allowed to vote, or why some states are still trying to suppress their votes.
“Let’s start with why Blacks were not counted as whole people in our Constitution”. You taught US History? Then you would know that proponents of slavery wanted Blacks to be counted as whole persons.
Perhaps we could start by reading The Federalist No.54, written by Madison.
Bob One, Massachusetts was brought into the Union as slave free because one of my ancestors sons-in-law, who was a lawyer in the first 13 colonies, interpreted the Constitutions as meaning all men (and women too) were created equal. A black women servant asked him if it meant her, too, and he said, “Yes,” and she was freed, although it was said she ran the whole household. That ancestor might be one of yours, too, as you once said your ancestry goes back to the colonies.
My point: not everything is in all the history books.
I understand that it is masters level coursework. It is in law school.
My experience with textbooks in history is that the treatment is cursory. I think that is why we always had research papers to do.
I would have to study what you are referring to. I live in an area where poverty is high but it is mostly white people (women and children). Poverty may be the real barrier although wealthy black people can be called names. But I think about Jimmy Carter who was still called a name for southerners even after being President of the United States.
Sometimes the barriers to equality are in the person’s thinking. You hear a lot about representation and how meaningful it is to Asian, Latino and black girls to see others of their race in positions in media. I have not heard of this from men. But that is media. Media was slow to come around to accepting people of color.. But why did they need to see someone “who looked like them” to believe that they could do it too?
My experience is with the engineering and science fields where a black woman can make 3 times what a white man makes. There was a conscious effort to boost people of color and females starting in the 1970s. 50 years later, it is a great living but there still are not many black females in it. Of course the more black females that get into it the more the difference will close because there are only so many positions of leadership.
Black voting history is not as cut and dried as Bob One makes it seem. Each state was allowed to form its voting laws. Some states did allow black males to vote although later, in some states, their right to vote was removed.
Many states had property ownership as a necessity to vote.
Most states did not permit any woman to vote, although one did allow widows and spinsters to vote.
To Bob One 5:03
So we must eliminate white racism, especially those which present barriers to black people, as they are pernicious effects of white culture. OK, Bob, Also requiring elimination (since they were inventions of white people): Basketball, Baseball, Football, Soccer.
(According to crt): These sports must be eliminated, since they are white cultural inventions and constructs.
And also requiring elimination are TV, Computers, Hospitals, Schools, Automobiles, Airplanes, Ships, Books….
They were all invented by whites and are now dominant in our culture, solely due to white prejudice (according to crt theory).
Bob one, as a proponent of crt and very enthusiastic about its promulgation, you must agree that these are all due to white society and culture, and must be eliminated. (crt: Hospitals and Schools must go. now.)
“Race is a political construction that was invented by white people to give themselves power while excluding all other races from it, and racism is the ordinary state of affairs in society, present in all interactions, institutions, and phenomena, and effectively permanent in society (short of a full sociocultural revolution that puts them in charge). That is, Critical Race Theory assumes that racism is present in everything under a doctrine known as “systemic racism.” Quoting from Delgado and Stefancic,(a crt textbook)
So only white people are racist by crt definition. – which is a totally racist concept in itself.
Everybody is racist – it is a part of being a human being. Our families, individual culture and society are more dear to us, than other groups. And if you think other races are not racist, you are incorrect. For example, look at the Mayor of Chicago: “I will only talk to reporters who are not white”. And, almost all of her hired coworkers are of her race. Also, the culture of Japan. Non-Japanese are not accepted there as equal citizens – it is a closed society. Examine every Muslim country – Christians are openly persecuted, and although this is not racist, it surely is indicative of human prejudice to the outsider.
So Bob One, explain again why crt proponents have the right to hang a racist card around the neck of every young white student in elementary school.
Aside from the fact that these are Jesuit’s which should tell you a lot, CRT is destroying our very fragile fabric in the US, pitting races against one another and worse yet children against one another, to tell white children and yes this is happening as we speak that they are evil and guilty of the past is pure evil at its core. All races are equal in the eyes of God and if this country is so racist why are hundreds of thousands of people pouring into our country through the open Southern border? Not just Mexicans and Central Americans, but people from Ghana, Syria, Haiti, Brazil, Nigeria, Iraq many with Covid 19 and the Biden gang are giving them free flights and buses to all parts of the United States and we sit here and let this happen, so if Covid is so rampant and we American citizens are told to just cover our faces, close our businesses and obey and shut up why is it that all of these illegal migrants are give free hotels, bus fare and flights all over the US to spread like wild fire Covid? Folks we are being played for fools as the Left destroys our country right before our very eyes. Like him or not everything Trump warned us about has come to true, as he said on many occasions the Left are coming for you he is only in there way, the Left control everything The president, house, senate, Hollywood, Academia, Sports, and yes even the U.S. military which is 100% woke now.
Everything the Lord warned us about is coming true.
Blessed is the nation whose God is the Lord. Ps 33:12
Repent of every sin and evangelize-tell the Good News. People especially the young are thirsty for it.
Best that this gets a full airing before the start of the school year or as soon as possible. Parents and families make great sacrifices to send their young men to a private Catholic school. If CRT, in its present form, is advocated there then the financial supporters of those students, and of the school population in general, should be advised of that in the clearest terms – from the desk of the Principal – describing what is being taught on this subject and how it is being taught. An open forum with parents would also seem appropriate. Parents and family members are investing hard-earned monies and are making many great sacrifices for this educational experience. If the school administration, or the Jesuit Order, is unwilling or arrogant enough to refuse to define, with precision, the presentation of this admittedly controversial subject, then those paying the bill can make decisions appropriately. This can’t be swept under the rug, ignored, or otherwise glossed over. Without a full airing Jesuit’s long and storied history will crumble in the short period of one academic year. Closure would follow immenently and completely.