Sir Robert, Lord Winston, at 86, is not just an elder statesman of the science of human fertility, but may be said to be a major founder of the IVF industry: IVF being in vitro fertilisation: the creation of a human being outside the womb, in vitro, in glass, that is to say, in a test tube. As can happen with pioneers, he is not altogether pleased with what he helped to create: I don’t mean the human beings who have been born as a result of the procedure, but the $23 billion industry which exploits their would-be parents.

This emerged in a recent interview on the Triggernometry podcast, headlined “The IVF pioneer who says his own industry is lying”. The natural desire for children, for all the low birthrates of much of the world, has provided easy prey to those who use the techniques Winston developed to rake in staggering amounts of money. In the interview, Winston, loaded with honours for his work as he is, including a peerage, pointed out IVF’s shockingly low success rate: even after six attempts only 34% of patients end up with a baby. As he put it: “In Vitro fertilisation becomes a torture because you end up with women, if they can afford it, going for 18 cycles of IVF, they become professional patients.”

Equally shocking is the fact that the financial incentives for IVF clinics are such that they have no interest in investigating why a couple has not had children naturally. In many cases, Winston explained, relatively simple and inexpensive (and, one could add, ethical) medical interventions could deal with the issue, or the problem could be solved by weight loss, or simply by perseverance. Once a couple has come through the doors of an IVF clinic, however, they are on a production line that leads though multiple invasive medical techniques, if not to a bouncing baby, then at least to a hefty bill.

It was interesting to hear the father of IVF tell these home truths, which tend to be swept under the carpet by the media. He has already been cancelled to an extent, in fact, for saying on the BBC Newsnight programme that human beings cannot change sex (he’s never been asked back). However, it is not that uncommon for pioneers to be disappointed by what is done with their ideas.

For example, Larry Sanger, one of the two founders of Wikipedia, has so annoyed the Wikipedians with his criticisms that he has been permanently banned from editing it. Again, plenty of political revolutionaries have been distressed by the way their revolutions have panned out, and indeed nearly all of the early leaders of the French and Russian revolutions ended up being murdered by their comrades. However, Lord Winston has something in common with the likes of Robespierre and Trotsky in that, while he has a lot of harsh things to say about how his work has been developed and used, he is unwilling to question its first principles. In his case, this would be the wisdom of separating the generation of offspring from the marital act.

Winston lived and campaigned through the entire process of the transformation of public opinion about IVF, moving between Britain and America to seek out funding and the laxest regulations. He not only dismisses the arguments against IVF, but gives the impression of never having taken the trouble to understand them. He repeats the talking point that St Thomas Aquinas did not think that the soul enters the human foetus until it has been 20 days in the womb, but fails to mention that Aquinas’ reason for thinking this is an Aristotelian account of human gestation which he himself rejects, and that in any case Aquinas still thought it wrong to procure an abortion, even before what was called the “quickening” of the baby.

His favourite response to criticisms, in fact, is that objectors are motivated by religion: in his mind, this seems to be a sufficient rebuttal, as if no religious tradition had any contribution to make to ethics. Like everyone of his generation brought up in the West, however, Winston’s own ethical ideals are heavily dependent on the Christian tradition, and it would be interesting to see him trying to justify his moral instincts without reference to assumptions which have been inculcated into Western culture by two millennia of Church teaching, such as on the dignity of the individual. Place Lord Winston in a culture where this is not taken for granted – and there are and have been many such cultures – and it is difficult to know what he would be able to say to defend any moral principle at all. Why shouldn’t IVF practitioners fleece desperate couples? Why shouldn’t they experiment on primates, something Winston strongly opposes? Then again, why shouldn’t we raid the neighbouring village, kidnap their children, and use them as slaves?

It is the role of Divine Revelation and the Church, not to invent moral principles out of the air, but to free human reason from the confusion and self-serving short-sightedness that obscure our understanding: for these principles are written on every human heart. When Winston came up against the overwhelming moral intuition that conceiving human babies outside the womb was wrong, back in the 1960s and 1970s, he should have stopped to think. Instead, convinced that he was right and that everyone else was wrong, he set about undermining this consensus, using the twin means most loved by progressives: the lure of self-interest (childless couples want children), and the threat of low status. If you agree with the age-old principles, the argument went, you must be an ignorant religious bigot, and heartless to boot.

He won, and now he is rather horrified by the monster that has emerged as a result. Medics are exploiting the possibilities offered by a technology that denies human dignity, to exploit the patients: is this really surprising? Doctors who, in order to create one life, routinely end several others, are not quite the selfless heroes we would like them to be, who would risk losing a fat fee by suggesting alternative courses of treatment: is this shocking?

The moral instinct that IVF is not right is, as I say, a powerful one, but the social pressure against expressing it in polite company has become equally powerful. The fact that IVF, as I have just noted in passing, standardly involves the destruction of “spare” embryos creates an overlap with abortion, but even some people who oppose abortion find it difficult to oppose IVF. However, this is not the fundamental problem with it. Even if, as would in theory be possible, though time consuming and expensive, only one embryo were created in vitro, it would still be gravely wrong.

To articulate exactly why requires an argument that parallels the argument against contraception. In the case of contraception, the intention to suppress the procreative potential of the sexual act is contrary to the nature and dignity of the act. This was expressed helpfully by the late Professor Germain Grisez in terms of the “unitive” role of the sexual act. It is because the couple become a single reproductive principle (between them, these two individuals can conceive a baby), that the act can be said to join them together as a couple: emotionally and spiritually.

What IVF does is to remove reproduction from the sexual act, removing it from the relationship of the couple. Just as contraception violates the meaning, the teleology, of the sexual act, so does IVF: the one by attempting to prevent conception, the other by bypassing the act itself.

Some people may be surprised that the sexual act is regarded as having such positive significance in Catholic theology. However, this is no recent innovation. Contraception always been condemned by the Church, and in the ancient world, before the Church’s influence was entrenched, many methods of contraception and indeed abortion were in use. Then again, Christian marriage is completed, literally “consummated”, by the marital act: if this does not take place, the marriage, though valid, can still be dissolved. The sexual act joins the couple together. This itself helps to explain why it is such a problem to engage in the act without the marriage vows: the vows create the act’s morally necessary context of commitment.

What we are offered in the technological dystopia pioneered by Lord Winston and his collaborators is the possibility of creating babies, not through a couple united by marriage, but by machine. It is an offense against human dignity which commodifies human beings, as if they were industrial products. Winston and other defenders of IVF do not offer us an alternative, consistent view of the dignity of sex, marriage, and parenthood, and no doubt would not regard that as lying within their area of expertise. All they can do is to deny what ordinary human decency recognises: that babies should not be the products of a technological process.

From Tradition and Sanity