Ignatius Press, the primary English-language publisher of the works of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, has published more than 80 books either written by him or about him, including the New York Times bestseller Jesus of Nazareth and influential books that continue to remain important for the contemporary Church, such as Introduction to Christianity and The Spirit of the Liturgy. Ignatius Press’ leadership and authors it represents comment on the death of Benedict and his remarkable legacy below:
Joseph Fessio, S.J., founder and editor, Ignatius Press; doctorate directed by Professor Joseph Ratzinger, University of Regensburg:
“I don’t believe being pope is a proof of sanctity, nor is it sufficient grounds for canonization. But being Joseph Ratzinger is. I don’t know anyone who has worked closely with him who does not recognize his holiness and his brilliance. In addition to hoping for santo subito, I look forward to his being declared a doctor of the Church.”
Mark Brumley, president of Ignatius Press:
“Benedict XVI was a major figure in Church history and world history. He was one of the great theologians and churchmen of the 20th and early 21st centuries. Along with Pope John Paul II, he served the Lord and his people mightily by helping the Catholic Church faithfully embrace reform in continuity, rather than either radical rupture or an uncritical return to the past. He was a major force for evangelical fidelity and engagement with the modern world. He was a man of God, a disciple of Jesus, and bearer of the Holy Spirit, who helped keep us on the right path. Thanks be to God for Joseph Ratzinger/Benedict XVI.”
Father D. Vincent Twomey, SVD; former doctoral student and longtime friend of Joseph Ratzinger; and Professor Emeritus of Theology, St Patrick’s Pontifical University, Maynooth, Ireland:
“Joseph Ratzinger/Pope Benedict XVI will be remembered above all for his literary and scholarly output. His writings on a vast spectrum of theological and philosophical topics have a clarity and a depth that make his theology inspiring and therefore liberating. His theology also stimulates further scholarly research, since all he could ever do was sketch the contours of the truth. Future generations of all walks of life will find inspiration in his homilies and in his pastoral writings as Pope; his encyclicals on love and hope must rank among the most outstanding ever to come from the pen of a Pope. It will come as no surprise to me, if in the future, he will be declared a Doctor of the Church.”
George Weigel, distinguished senior fellow and William E. Simon Chair in Catholic Studies, Ethics and Public Policy Center:
“Joseph Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI, was one of the most creative Catholic theologians of modern times and arguably the greatest papal preacher since Pope St. Gregory the Great. In the more than thirty years I knew him and was in conversation with him, I found him to be a consummate Christian gentleman, a man of deep faith and sweet temper. It has been my privilege to have been taught by and to work with many brilliant men and women; no one I’ve ever met had a more lucid or orderly mind than Joseph Ratzinger. He believed that the truth of the Gospel was the truth of the world, and he bent every effort to help others understand that truth.”
Tim Gray, president of the Augustine Institute:
“Pope Benedict XVI blessed the Church by exemplifying what faith seeking understanding looks like in postmodernity. Humbly complementing his friend and predecessor, Pope Saint John Paul the Great, he showed how the Second Vatican Council faithfully applied the Word of God and the gospel proclamation as the way for us to navigate the crisis of truth we now face. I particularly think his Encyclical Letter on Hope, ‘Spe Salvi,’ was prophetic. He spoke of the hope that challenges us to give up comfort in order to embrace the cross, striving forward for the hope Christ has stored up for us in heaven. I pray he may now realize the hope he cherished and the hope he challenged the Church to hold to above all others.”
Robert Royal, president of the Faith & Reason Institute:
“All of us must die, and the passing of most of us is of little consequence in the vast sweep of sacred history. But Pope Benedict’s death marks the end of a monumental life that changed the Church — and the world — and will continue to do so for many years to come. In his brilliance, imagination, humility and steady faith, he resembled the Church Fathers, whom he loved and studied and brought to bear on our troubled age. He belongs in their company and should be named a Doctor of the Church. God grant him the eternal reward that he so richly merits.”
Professor Tracey Rowland, John Paul II Chair of Theology at the University of Notre Dame (Australia):
“Pope Benedict XVI was one of the most learned men ever to occupy the Petrine Office. I believe that future generations will honor him with the title of Church Doctor. His intellectual legacy is immense and at least on par with St John Henry Newman, one of the intellectual heroes of his youth. He never lost the faith of his Bavarian boyhood and he defended it intellectually on the stage of the world. He understood the theological roots of the cultural crisis of the Western world better than any world leader of his generation.”
Dr. Peter Kreeft, professor of philosophy, Boston College; author of Wisdom From the Psalms:
“Pope Benedict XVI was a gift of God, one of the very best teachers we have ever had, an equal to Gregory the Great, Leo the Great, and Leo XIII. A shoo-in for Saint and eventually a Doctor of the Church.”
Story sent via Christian Newswire.
Very good article! Santo subito, for our late, great, saintly Pope Benedict. And may he soon be made a Doctor of the Church.
Professor Rowland “He understood the theological roots of the cultural crisis of the Western world better than any world leader of his generation.” High praise from the professor and from others; therefore I ask: did Benedict not see his value to the Church that others here claim for him? A man so gifted yet can’t see the need for these gifts at this particular time with Western culture in such terrible decline? Someone with deeper insight into the matter has to help me with this, and I welcome any contributions.
“It was an absolute act of humility,” Bishop Stika said. “I think he wrote in his book that his doctor told him he could no longer travel as pope due to his health. He recognized that part of the role of the pope these days is to travel like St. Paul. I think with his health issues, it was a great act of humility to say, I will step back and let a new man take my place and I will offer my life now in terms of prayer for the Church, which he did.”
Bishop Stika is Bishop of Knoxville
I also think Benedict saw first hand what it was like to have a Pope whose health stood in the way of the pressing needs of the office, and he didn’t want to be that Pope. An act of humility, absolutely, and of wise governance.
For all we know, he lived longer than he or anyone thought possible, due to the intercession of St John Paul II.
I am sure for most Catholics he will be remembered as the Pope who quit.
I think Summorum Pontificum was a significant moment as well as the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX bishops without their repentance.
He waived the 5 year requirement for sainthood for JP II which I did not agree with.
I remember an incident where he had to apologize for something he said about Muslims.
I tried to read his documents but I could not really understand them.
I think he had a huge impact, as anyone would, as prefect for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
I do not know whether he or St. JPII started the catechism at the Angelus on Wednesday. I do not know how much of an impact it had.
The quotes above don’t really say what he did or said that he should be made a saint or a Doctor of the Church.
Father Fessio
https://catholicreview.org/he-did-all-things-well-benedicts-former-student-reflects-on-his-mentor/
“His insistence on the continuity of the church before and after Vatican Council — that was an important part of his papacy. In fact, he emphasized that in the very first talk he gave when he was made pope. He was elected around 6:30 at night, and the next morning at 9:30 he gave a talk in Latin, which he himself wrote without any help, and he made it very clear that he was a pope of the council — but that we had to see the council not as a rupture from previous church teaching, but rather in continuity with it.”
https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2022/12/31/a-timeline-of-pope-benedict-xvis-extraordinary-life/
https://www.vatican.va/special/annus_fidei/documents/annus-fidei_bxvi_inedito-50-concilio_en.html
Pope Benedict’s reflection on the 50th anniversary of Vatican II
“It was a privilege to participate in the election of Pope Benedict. I can remember when I went up to the pope and knelt before him to show my respect and offer to him my pledge to be faithful and obedient, the first thing that Pope Benedict said to me was, ‘Happy Birthday, your eminence.’ It was my 70th birthday. Pope Benedict remembered that, and that is a memory I will always carry with me.”
Cardinal Justin Rigali
I do not like lay (or clergy) canonizations.
If he is found to have lived a life of sanctity and there are two miracles after his death, then the Church might declare that he is a saint.
Then, he is a saint.
If a future Pope (or the current one) makes the decision that he is a Doctor of the Church, then he is a Doctor of the Church.
I am not a professional Catholic or even an expert, but even I know this.
The conservatives and the latinistas are, of course, already advocating sainthood for Pope Benedict XVI. Let the process proceed and allow for as much time as necessary. The process of sainthood for Pope JPII was accelerated after which we learned of a questionable relationship with a woman when he was Archbishop.