Watch the discussion between Vivian Dudro (an Ignatius Press editor), Father Fessio, founder of Ignatius Press, and Joseph Pearce, an author published by Ignatius Press, who talk about Hans Urs von Balthasar’s book, Dare we hope that all men be saved?
Father Fessio takes blame for Von Balthasar controversy on Hell
'Dare we hope that all men be saved?'
-

"The German title is Was durfen wir hoffen? (What may we hope for?)"
Related Posts
7 Comments
Leave A Comment Cancel reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.






I remember reading the book when it came out from Ignatius Press but my poor memory fails me to the extent that I cannot register approval or disdain. I did listen to the podcast, however, and wonder if there is a bit of hand-waving in Fr. Fessio’s analysis. For he says if anyone claims not all are saved, we are thereby obligated to name those for whom we ought not hope for their salvation. The idea is that we should hope every one of these unfortunates might be saved, and if we hope thusly we can be sure God also desires this. To claim anyone is not saved puts us in the unenviable position of knowing as God knows. But if we believe persistent and obstinate sinners ought not hope for salvation save they believe in the forgiveness of sins through Jesus Christ, we needn’t decide who is saved and who is damned, only that necessity is laid upon us to spread the Word of repentance and faith in our Lord. The question is, has God given us enough insight into Divine Justice and Mercy so that we can hope all are saved and be on good grounds for doing so? My reading of the New Testament leads me to believe the grounds are very shaky for such optimism. And despite what tangential universalists have said, the New Testament is our only sure source for delving into this subject.
If everyone is saved, there’s no point in being Catholic. There’s no point in going to Sunday Mass. There’s no point in adhering to the moral law. There’s no reason not to indulge your every sinful desire. There’s no point in making “holy” sacrifices. There’s no good reason to be a martyr.
Because, you see, if everyone is saved, then piety and spiritual discipline make no essential difference in ultimate, eternal outcomes. Some might claim there will be a difference in the degree of beatitude between the advanced saints and the lesser saints. But even the lesser saints will experience ultimate, everlasting joy in the beatific vision, and they won’t be aware that they are missing out on any greater degree of perfection that they could have had, otherwise they would be sad about their lack of progress, but no sadness can exist in heaven.
“Everyone is saved” is just soteriological DEI and affirmative action. It’s the soteriological equivalent of open borders and illegal immigration.
I read a ridiculous essay this morning that theorized that the disabled will not have their disabilities fixed in heaven. To claim that disabilities are fixed in the resurrected body is a form of “ableism”, so claimed the author: saying that able bodies are superior to disabled bodies.
What is happening to theology that leftist ideas are distorting the faith? We are making man the measure of things instead of God.
Von Balthasar, to be fair, did not posit that everyone was saved; only that it is legitimate for us to hope for this outcome. Back in the late 70s a young diocesan priest from the Archdiocese of Los Angeles was serving in a parish near where I lived, and he held firmly the universalist tenant that there was no hell. So it is perhaps true that the having hope that all might be saved can easily transition from hope to conviction that this is so. How widespread this priest’s beliefs are shared by his fellow priests here in Los Angeles I’m sure I have no idea. I can’t recall in my 46 years as a Catholic (convert) ever hearing mention of hell in a homily. Our present pope finds himself somewhere between hope and conviction: ““What I am going to say is not a dogma of faith but my own personal view: I like to think of hell as empty; I hope it is.”(Rome Newsroom, Jan 15, 2024). I agree with you that if everyone is known to be saved then all calls to repentance and faith unto salvation through Jesus Christ are pointless. Jesus, the apostles, and all others preaching conversion throughout the Church’s history just didn’t get it, according to this DEI dogma.
If any individual man can be saved by his acceptance of God’s grace (which we must believe to avoid Calvin’s double predestination) then in theory all men could be saved. We are allowed, however, to doubt that probability. Jesus’ words in the Scriptures suggest that Hell is in fact already occupied, and so do the visions of the mystics. Our Lady showed a vision of Hell to the children of Fatima, with sinners suffering, and who would dare suggest the Blessed Mother showed only a “possible” Hell? If we wish to avoid damnation, we’d best keep it in mind as a real possibility and avoid speculation on Infernal demographics.
I wouldn’t want to be in heaven with the likes of people like Obama, Clinton, Pelosi, Biden, Kerry, Newsom, Harris, Schumer, Whitmer, Ketanji, Sotomayor, Kagan… you get the idea.
Knowing they got to be in heaven would ruin it for me. And that would last forever because heaven is forever. I’d be like, “Look what the dog brought in.”
Who knows? If they repent before death and you and I are there, we may be all together. And, don’t worry about who the dog drags in, whether any of them or you or me. Purgation cleans us all up before seeing God face to Face. I pray the Hound of Heaven brings me in.
https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/hound-of-heaven-4117
Well said! I’m sure we should hope for all Christ’s enemies to bow willingly and faithfully at his feet, even if the reality turns out, with good reason, to be very different. I think this is the spirit of Von Balthasar, at least as far as I can go with him.