There are Christians of my acquaintance who are against the legalization of same-sex “marriage” and its threat to religious liberty, but cannot see how their attendance at a gay friend’s wedding would undermine those values and their Christian witness. Quite the opposite, they believe that declining the invitation would be hurtful to their friend and contrary to the ethic of Christian love.
Although homosexuality affects only about two percent of the population, most people know someone—a coworker, friend, cousin, son, or daughter—who is gay or lesbian. As more gays take to the altar, the chance that you will be invited to a ceremony becomes increasingly likely.
The Significance of Attendance
A wedding is a solemnizing ceremony that attendees come to witness, honor, and bless through liturgy, songs, and celebratory expressions—applause, cheers, toasts, well wishes—that serve to give social and moral validation to the union of two people.
A Christian who thinks that, by attending, he can support his gay friend but not gay “marriage” is sorely mistaken. Attendance, in and of itself, is more than a show of support for the individuals involved; it dignifies a transmogrified sexual union and the institution sanctioning it.
Even passive attendance confers approval, most pointedly when the officiant perfunctorily asks, “Does anybody have any reason why these two should not be married?” and the believer, not wanting to break with decorum, remains silent.
Across the country, organizations and individuals are being sued and forced out of business for refusing to offer adoption services to same-sex couples, promote the “virtues” of homosexuality to their foster children, and provide services for same-sex weddings.
When a Christian attends a gay wedding, he undermines the courageous stand for religious freedom these people are making for him, at great personal cost. He adds credence to the opinion that religious objections to “marriage equality” are fig leaves for animus and bigotry toward gays. It’s an opinion that has gained currency in courts and legislatures and is causing the erosion of “conscience clauses” and “religious exemptions” in the public and private sectors.
Supporting a Gay Friend
Christian friendship is not based on approval or agreement, but love—sacrificial other-centeredness that seeks the supreme good of others, desiring them to become the persons they were created to be: children of the Father, formed in the image of the Son, and indwelt by the Spirit.
Christ demonstrated that love not by affirming us in our sins, but by dying for our sins, calling us to repentance, and showing us how to live according to his life-giving principles. He who commanded his disciples to love as he loved, also said, “Those whom I love I rebuke and discipline.” And those he loved, felt the sting of his rebuke on numerous occasions, and were instructed to do likewise (“If your brother sins, rebuke him”).
Loving our friends and relatives, gay or straight, is not supporting them in immoral and harmful lifestyle decisions, it’s walking alongside them, encouraging them to live in accordance with the created purpose of sexuality, and challenging, even rebuking them when they willfully choose otherwise.
Attending a gay friend’s wedding is just as contrary to Christ-love as it is for attending: the marriage of a friend who left his wife for his “soul mate,” a house-warming party for cohabiting couple, or a friend’s abortion party (yes, there is such a thing).
Christ-love demands that I graciously decline the invitation (preferably, face-to-face) with an honest and clear explanation of my reasons. To go-along-to-get-along is to allow fears about my friend’s feelings and our relationship, to overcome my concern for his soul and his relationship with God. That’s not love; it’s cowardice.
And while our friendship, if close, should survive and even thrive a loving reproof, there is always the risk it will cause a rift, possibly permanently. Did not Jesus warn that he came “to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law” and, I add, friend against friend?
However, the outcome of a rebuke lovingly done is on the receiver and God, not deliverer. For, as St. Theresa of Calcutta once said “God does not require that we be successful only that we be faithful,” the measure of which is not when it’s easy, at the ballot box, but when it’s hard, telling a friend or relative, no. Indeed, now that homosexual pseudotrimony is law, people who were opposed to it in principle, will have to decide if they will oppose it in practice.
Full story at Crisis Magazine.
These are difficult choices because we are, by nature, weak and limited in our understanding of Christ and His message of Charity. The article is essentially correct, though, you must not give public sanction to an inherently sinful event. It might cause you to lose a friend or family member’s love; homosexual sexualists refuse to see any moral value in Catholic doctrine. Wasn’t it some vile California billionaire that is spending millions to challenge state laws seeking to stop changes in laws demanded by homosexual activists; he called the State legislators the evil ones, as I recall. They are not just trying to be like everyone else.
If the article is “correct” as you say, then why does ever Catholic priest I know disagree? I mean, I’m sure there are some that do agree. I just don’t any, though, and I know at least 10 priests.
Don’t go to the wedding, and tell them why. When they invite you, typically they aren’t looking for your approval but rather, for you to celebrate with them. You can’t. And don’t send a gift either.
As Catholics, we understand that encouraging one in their sin is actually a sin, so tell them you cannot celebrate that which you know to be sinful. Sure, they won’t like it or understand, but you must do the right thing. Your soul is more important than a slice of cake or an invitation to Thanksgiving dinner.
“Have you not heard that the Church is considering a “blessing” for married same sex couples? Doesn’t sound like the Church thinks they are living in sin to me.
When two friends get married, it’s about THEM, it’s not about YOU. It’s not about YOUR religion, YOUR opinion of whether the bride is beautiful or the cake delicious, or even whether the two people make a good match. And it is most certainly not about whether YOU are expressing support for some florist or baker not even remotely connected to this wedding. Would you not attend a wedding because they didn’t use your caterer brother? Of course you wouldn’t, because to do so would seem petty. And it would be petty to use such silly reasons to betray your friendship.
If it’s about THEM, is it also not about THEIR eternal salvation?
Why, because it’s all about YOU Ron? You have some high level of intellect that we all should aspire to?
No, YFC, by our presence we should not give to others the false impression that we concur in the sinful choice they have made. Perhaps a better approach would be to affirm our and God’s love for the couple, explain w/o polemics why we cannot witness it as true—and then attend the wedding, not OK’ing the choice the couple has made but, while disagreeing heartily with it, re-express our love for them even in their sincere mistake. Just say: You know I can’t agree with your choice, but that won’t keep me from respecting you and loving you as God does as I have always done. Then, without expressing it to them, pray that they can live out their love consistent with God’s teaching. How does that strike you?
No it is NOT about their eternal salvation. That’s an outdated, and laughable (sorry, but true) belief.
YFC, I was told by my pastor that I should attend the wedding of a Catholic who was divorced and remarrying in a civil ceremony. I prayed for their souls the whole time. I did not applaud when they were married. I still feel bad about attending and I wish I had not gone. I still pray for them and their unbaptized children.
“Your Fellow Catholic” is correct, it is about “THEM.” And, to make it about them, you need to stand up for the Faith, as their homosexual actions (in which they are obviously engaging) threaten to lead them to Hell. If you care about them as people, speak to them about why you cannot stand there with them as any kind of symbol of their celebration. Your choice, then, is solely about THEM. The much easier thing to do would be to cave in and attend, rather than risk the sure-to-come opposition and scorn from other wedding goers.
Not an easy decision to stay away, but the right, and only, one.
YFC it is time for you to “come out.” and tell readers how yoy practise your homosexuality
YFC how foolish, its about being a Sacrament. And your title reads “Your Fellow Catholic” ? Being Catholic is to say, “stop what invites you to the fires of Hell “. Satan is licking his chops.
You should take “Catholic” out of your screen name. What you are standing for is not Catholic, it’s anti-Catholic. Learn Catholic teachings before you attempt to educate others. Or be who you truly are-a non Catholic, congruent with your expresses views.
It is better to betray a “friendship” than to betray God.
YFC, with respect to your 1st sentence, I can’t entirely agree. To practice our faith in integrity, we can’t be seen to accept same sex-marriage as morally permissible. That said, suppose prior to the wedding, we made our moral reservations known privately and politely. But then stressed our legitimate moral conclusion that God loves them both–as He has always done–and that we continue to love and respect them as people close to us, as God does, despite our disagreement. Then attend the wedding as a testament to two people you have always loved and respected—even thru disagreements in addition to the present one. That strikes me as OK. How does it strike you?
You would be condoning it if you went! Playing a part in this sad situation.
Pray for them that they will have a conversion.
When you proclaim the word of God and Gospel message in all truth and sincerity this is not a silly reason or a betrayal of your friendship. We are called by our faith to follow the laws of Almighty God no matter what the world thinks or does. If your friend is a true friend they would and should accept your refusal to attend an event that is contrary to the laws of God and personal beliefs. The act of sodomy between two men is seriously rebuked by Almighty God throughout the bible. How then can an act that is so seriously rebuked by God then be solemnized in a wedding ceremony. That’s the real conundrum that those taking part in homosexual marriage make. Seek God’s love and mercy or face his divine retribution. Pray Pray Pray!
YFC: Once again you are completely out of touch with reality and objective truth. “Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt”. You waste your time and this space with your Intellectually challenged tripe.
What should I do? One of my nephews, who is a chaste homosexual, will be ordained as a Roman Catholic priest next June. Should I attend or not? Gift or no gift?
Point of clarification: If your nephew is chaste, how do you know he is homosexual?
Larry… I came out to my Aunt before I told my parents.
Are you the nephew of George who is being ordained?
Oh Lordy no Larry. First, I’m a woman and secondly, I don’t think I’m smart enough to be a priest. My point was that sometimes, some of us will confide in a trusted, loving aunt or uncle before anyone else.
Probably not. quote: “Whether he is celibate or not, the person who views himself as a ‘homosexual person,’ rather than as a person called to be a spiritual father — that person should not be a priest,” said Father Toups, of the bishops’ conference”
MARY, BUT WHAT DID THE POPE SAY?
A sympathy card should suffice.
Very disappointing in my life not to be able to attend invalid weddings of beloved family and friends who are Catholic but were married out of the Church. But I know i did the right thing by not condoning those legal only unions. I would never attend and celebrate with people who are destroying themselves in unnatural and invalid unions.
This reminds me of the absolute prohibition of decades ago against Catholics attending services at Protestant or other Houses of Worship. Perhaps one should not be an active participant, such as Best Man or Maid of Honor. Perhaps simply attending is at a significantly different level.
If a ‘friend’ is the one getting married, then would not logic say the mere status as ‘friend’ implies an unacceptable level of approval?
Actually, a friendship with a gay person and a straight person is like any other friendship. Each person has their boundaries. If aserious boundary is crossed, the friendship dies. If a gay person wants to not be friends because you can’t attend his or her wedding,then you lovingly send them into their future with your prayers. It’s painful but probably for the best. Forgive them and move on.
The Gaystapo – Including the ‘Paid?’ Homosex Trolls monitoring this board, are growing ever more Vicious
I just had my Face-Bunk account (and Archives) destroyed by the PC Thought Police, in Retaliation for daring to pose politically Un-Good Facts about them
If you check you will find that Years of Archived Links are now Missing form the Cal-Catholic website
I am not alone – in fact I consider myself in Good Company – SEE:
The Crucifixion of Pastor Scott Lively
https://barbwire.com/2014/11/15/crucifixion-pastor-scott-lively/
Christians, pastors, take heed. In case you haven’t noticed, times are a-changin’. Whether at home or abroad, if you follow God’s command to speak biblical truth in all things, most especially, it seems, on…
‘Don’t feed the trolls’ really is good advice – here’s the evidence
https://theconversation.com/dont-feed-the-trolls-really-is-good-advice-heres-the-evidence-63657
Research has defined a typical troll as an internet user who takes on a fake identity, which they then use to cause disruption and trigger conflict among others for their own amusement.
One way to try to understand why people engage in trolling is to investigate whether they are likely to show particular personality traits, such as narcissism, psychopathy, Machiavellianism and everyday sadism – known as the “dark tetrad”…
A 2014 study found that people with higher levels of sadism, psychopathy and Machiavellianism were more likely to engage in online trolling behaviour,…
‘Pander or Perish’ = In Real Time
Pastor Forced to Move After Receiving Threats for Opposing Facebook’s Rainbow Flag Emoji
https://www.christianpost.com/news/pastor-forced-move-receiving-threats-opposing-facebooks-rainbow-flag-emoji-193075/
A West Virginia pastor who has received threats and endured various other forms of harassment for voicing opposition to Facebook’s rainbow flag emoji has moved his family out of their home in Harpers Ferry after being advised by local police to do so because of safety concerns.
As previously reported, Pastor Rich Penkoski, who runs the online ministry “Warriors for Christ,” has received an immense amount of backlash from LGBT advocates after the popular Warriors for Christ Facebook page…
My personal experience is that when I was about to make a major life decision most people said that they would support me whatever I decided. One person said that what I was thinking about doing was wrong. I did not do it because of that one person.
Yes, everything is about homosexuals. The universe revolves around them. That is why we are treated to an endless parade of homosexual pride parades, homosexual marches, homosexual pride days, homosexual advocacy days, homosexual appreciation days, history lessons about homosexuals, homosexual sex education, …. Everyone else is a peasant whose concerns, struggles, and rights don’t really matter. Try to avoid baking a cake that promotes homosexual unions and see what happens to you.
This is the test. The voice of the world vs. the Word of God.
Dear YFC and TEM ,
I just received your invitation and must decline. As you know, I am a Roman Catholic, so attending your event would be a sin. However, I did get you a gift. Attached is the web address to the Catholic apostolate Courage, which I believe would be of great benefit to you both: https://couragerc.org/.
Regards, Papa Francis
Larry: my nephew told his family that he has a homosexual orientation; however, he does not engage in homosexual activities. He wants to be a faithful and holy priest!
I see. But then…why even tell in the first place? Why tell ANYBODY what temptations you have secretly rebuffed? I don’t see people wearing T-shirts that say, “I am a chaste heterosexual,” or “I would dearly love to murder certain people, but I have restrained myself” or “I have a bank-robbery inclination which I have never acted upon, and intend to never act upon.” The fact that he identifies his very being with a particular temptation tells me he’s bought into some unhealthy notions, which concerns me. But, if he’s determined to restrain himself, then go to the ordination!
Had things worked out differently I would have been a bride at a gay wedding. I wouldn’t have held it against anyone for not attending because of their beliefs.I would have said that their relationship with me now included Helen and that I expected that any invitations to weddings, Bat Mitzvas parties etc. to me would also include her.
Why would you commit such a serious sin?
There are plenty of homosexual Priests who were not able to be chaste once they came across some altar boys.
C&H I am curious had you been a bride at a “gay wedding” how could you reconcile this falseness with the Truth of the teaching of the Church, you would not be able to have receive communion despite the lies of liberal bishops, I want to know how you would have done this
Bohemond … As you know, the Church teaches that each of us must thoughtfully and prayerfully look into her or his conscience when making moral judgements.. After much such reflection, we believed that committing ourselves to a lifelong relationship, loving each other, loving others and loving and honoring God was the moral, Christian choice
Wrong. Making moral judgments necessitates an informed conscience in accordance with reason and divine law. As so many of your posts reveal, you willfully exercise erroneous judgment. Consequently, you lead others into error, a grave act indeed.
Drink more cool aid.
What you call “conscience” is nothing more or less than following your own will rather than the Father’s, which is more than clear regarding sexual acts between persons of the same sex. Remember Christ’s words: “Not everyone who says, ‘Lord, Lord’ will enter the Kingdom of Heaven, but he who does the will of my Father.”
C&H, your conscience must be properly formed, and if you insist that actively homosexual lifestyles are licit, then yours is not properly formed! This is a Catholic website, thus your personal errors in judgement must be countered. We must form our consciences to His, and pray for the grace to do so.
C&H, Loving someone is good. Sinning is not. I do not know if you committed sins in your relationship. I hoped you confessed if you did. I will pray for the repose of Helen’s soul. I will pray for you, too. I pray that you will always walk the Saving Way. Please pray for me.
I shall.
I wonder if Jesus would have attended the wedding. He hung out with prostitutes and tax collector didn’t he? How much worse would gays be? Gays are born in the image and likeness of God and are to be treated with dignity. That is what the church teaches, isn’t it?
Bob One, the Lord Jesus did not “hang” out with prostitutes nor tax collector to applaud what they did. He “hung” out with them to get them to repent, change their lives and often to make restitution for what they did. Remember? Zachias paid back all that he owed people and then some. The adulteress was told to go and sin no more lest something worse happen to her. In other words Christ was warning her not to do it again.
Actually, Bob One, He didn’t hangout, so to speak. He, as God become man, knew the hearts of those who sought Him. Thus, He sought and spent His time loving them into conversion. He, as only God can, loved them perfectly. Yes, the Catechism tells us that we must treat all persons with dignity for their inherent nature. However, you must not obfuscate the truth with fiction. The use of Sophistry is not treating Cal_Catholic commentators with dignity. The Catechism tells us that we must not resort to unjust discrimination. The key word is “unjust.” Catholics must apply just discrimination to the sin of sodomy. We are required to not validate any sin associated with the actions of those who practice homosexual behaviors, lest we incur sin…
Bob One, all Catholics are “obliged to oppose the legal recognition of homosexual unions” and where such unions are given the legal status and rights that belong to marriage, “clear and emphatic opposition is a duty,” said St. Pope John Paul II in a 2003 letter issued by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the current Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI. May God bless and keep you.
Oh my goodness – a new twyst to the WWJD argument, promoting the Cannibal Soup for Lunch Bunch of Bananas (aka Paid” homosex trolls on this board) – seeking to make analogous the fact that Jesus Wanted Sinners to Repent, and would reach out to them with encouragement to do so.
The bait is wanting to emulate Jesus in his Ministry – but the scam is to say that Jesus “Hung Out” with seedy types, so why shouldn’t you – and while you are attending a Cannibal Soup Party, maybe take a tiny sip of clear broth from the simmering Crock – for ‘tolerance’ sake.
Of course that would make you a Cannibal yourself – but only just a bit, some, rather a lot really (a recycled Monty Python Joke) – and instead of working to Help these folks turn…
Instead of working to help these folks turn it around, you would be the one ‘Turned’ – in to a PC Cannibal.
Most People – invited as Guests at a ‘Ceremony’ (its not a Wedding – but a marketing scam, like ‘free stuff’ to try out if you sign up for the mailing list) would feel uncomfortable standing up during the traditional “Is there Anyone Who Objects – or forever hold your opinion (under the soup until it drowns) – and would Not speak up because it would Ruin the Ceremony – which is just the Opposite of what Jesus was doing – openly telling Sinners to Stop, for their own good.
My menu recommendation – Don’t buy the ‘happy meal’ – even if gaily packaged in rainbow cartons
Michael, forgive me if I do you an injustice—but for one bemoaning the fixation on gay rights (and rightly, I add) it’s all you seem to post about. Lighten up for a while. They are NOT going to change.
Stop picking on Mike!