The following comes from a July 3 story on the website of the Cardinal Newman Society.
The website of an ethics program at Santa Clara University, a Jesuit institution, links to a pro-assisted suicide website as well as articles advocating positions contrary to Catholic moral teaching.
Under the banner “Bioethics,” the Jesuit institution’s Markkula Center for Applied Ethics has a section called “End of Life Ethics,” in which it links to a pro-assisted suicide website called the Compassion in Dying Federation.
The Markkula Center describes the Federation site with clear awareness of its purpose: “Site provides information regarding end-of-life choices with advocacy for assisted death. Also includes a good list of site links.”
Elsewhere on the University’s website, Mike Meyer, then-chair of Santa Clara University’s philosophy department and a faculty member with the Markkula Center, is quoted saying:
Suicide at the end of life is so much more likely to be a reasonable choice for an individual than suicide at any other point in life, that we ought to think of it as voluntary euthanasia so that the fair-minded social stigma at other times of life might be diminished or in the best cases simply eliminated.
…Suicide at the end of life might well be connected to a person’s sense of her dignity,while suicide at other times is altogether less likely to be a genuine issue of dignity.
The site also includes an essay by current philosophy professor Lawrence Nelson, who argues against the California Supreme Court’s ruling protecting the life of Robert Wendland from his wife, who sought to remove his feeding tube after an auto accident:
This group of judges got it wrong. Close family members should presumptively be the ones who decide when it is right to forgo treatment of their incompetent relative. As the New Jersey Supreme Court stated when strangers opposed a family’s decision to stop the tube feeding of their permanently unconscious relative, “Our common human experience informs us that family members…provide for the patient’s comfort, care, and best interests…, and [it is] they who treat the patient as a person, rather than a symbol of a cause.”
Both Nelson and Meyer were exposed in a 2011 Crisis Magazine article by Cardinal Newman Society president Patrick Reilly. The article reads in part:
An attorney who sought the “mercy killing” of a disabled but allegedly functioning California man is today a “faculty scholar” at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at the Jesuits’ Santa Clara University.
Fighting a challenge from the mother of Robert Wendland — who was severely disabled in a car accident in 1993 —Lawrence Nelson failed to convince the California Supreme Court to permit the removal of Wendland’s feeding tube. Wendland’s mother, Florence, presented evidence that Robert was not in a “persistent vegetative state” but could occasionally make limited movements, like writing the letter R. Nelson has since argued that “this was no life for Robert, no life he would ever want. The only experiences he seemed to have were negative.”
Not surprisingly, Nelson has also advocated the legalization of assisted suicide. In 1996, he joined an amicus brief in Vacco v. Quill and Washington v. Glucksberg, arguing that “the right of competent, dying patients to physician-assisted suicide is a negative right to be free from state interference.”
At Santa Clara University, Nelson has continued to work on end-of-life issues. In a Hastings Center Report article this year with significant application to the assisted-suicide debate, Nelson and co-author Brendan Ashby argue that doctors should have the freedom to decide whether they wish to participate in lethal injections for criminals who are condemned to death — a practice opposed by leading medical associations because it violates the mandate to heal and do no harm.
To read the original story, click here.
Why say you’re Catholic if you know better than God? I think the “Society of Jesus” should change their name to the “Society of Satan.” That way their theology, on this and other major theological issues, would not be in conflict with their purported allegiance.
Once again, the moral degradation of the San Jose Diocese on display.
This university is opening a theological center at Mission San Ruis Rey, San Diego. What is the Bishop of San Jose afraid off? Losing his soul or losing his prestige?
Sometime I wonder if some Bishops have not already lost their faith.
You are thinking of USD, not Santa Clara.
Isn’t it the Franciscan School of Theology that is affiliating with the University of San Diego?
https://fst.edu/admissions/apply-to-fst-at-old-mission-san-luis-rey/
If it okay for parents and doctors to murder their children before they are born, is it okay to murder them afterwards too? Slip-slidin’ toward that, folks. If it is okay to murder oneself when life gets tough, is it okay to kill yourself when you are bored, broke, or just plain unattractive? Slip-sliding toward finding all kinds of excuses not to carry our crosses and absolve ourselves of murder-tres convenient. If it is okay to kill oneself when life becomes tiresome, what about popping off others who have become tiresome, burdensome, or just plain hard to look at? Why now trim down the populace to only those of a certain age, type, look and usefulness? But hey, wait – what happens when time goes on and you yourself become aged, tiresome, burdensome and unattractive, to say nothing of self-supporting? Or what if you’re rich and your nephew needs money – bump you off? Whom is it okay to kill, and why and when? In a shifting culture, none of us is safe, from ourselves or others, if we even begin to play God. Let the living live, friends, even if that means you keep your kids and refrain from murdering them at any point, born or unborn, and you keep on trudging even when life gets challenging. That’s how you follow Jesus instead of playing God.
Father,
It was on display with the horrible treatment they gave the saintly Msgr. Sweeney. I was present when the Monsignor cried practically in the arms of my beloved Archbishop Khai and Archbishop Khai cried with him!
I was also present when McGrath went against Human Life International in favor of Jewish radicals even when one of the major speakers at that Conference was none other than Rabi Jehuda Levin!
McGrath will have a lot to answer for on his particular judgment day!
God bless, yours in Their Hearts,
Kenneth M. Fisher
Maryanne,
“If it okay for parents and doctors to murder their children before they are born, is it okay to murder them afterwards too?” Obama already had that covered when he was able to cheat his way into the Illinois Senate!
God bless, yours in Their Hearts,
Kenneth M. Fisher
The Jesuits, once again…Bishop McGrath, once again…
McGrath is the last person deserving of a defense on this stuff, but the Jesuit problem is so overwhelming, so culpable, so despicable, what’s the point of bringing up McGrath? The Jesuits have innumerable people comparable to him, yet we should single him out for not correcting his contemporaries? Ultimately, they all belong to the same club.
Markkula center profs Nelson & Meyer (sounds like a comedy team, maybe they are) seem happy to produce philosophical output equivalent to “a persistent vegetative state.” Would they not be hard-pressed to show that their work product is worthwhile enough to society that perhaps they should best be encouraged to practice their own self-annihilation recommendations? (“You two first, must be good, we’ll watch and see!”) No. Most leftists, tellingly, only want their toximia applied to others. Maybe if they were to lead by example and drink the hemlock, they would free up the two chairs in the Phil dept. to employ some young, deserving non-vegetative candidates. After all, Nelson and Meyer, how can you prove you are not worthlessly occupying these positions, having certainly had enough time there now, drawing a fat salary and benefits, sucking the university dry? And it is after all a zero-sum game. Jobs are scarce. Have at it, boys! I am sure the Kool-aid is sweet (altho with a bitter almond aftertaste).
The Jesuit society is itself in a persistent vegetative state. Maybe they’ll all get together and suicide themselves to show everyone the way.
Skai: “bitter almond aftertaste” is what I meant. It is a reference to cyanide, which is said to taste like bitter almonds (at least those who have tasted it in infinitesimal quantities and survived), and was used at Jonestown, Guiana by the messianic pastor Jim Jones.
correction: reply on ‘bitter almonds” was to Mr Fisher’s Q., not Skai’s.
Steve Phoenix,
Didn’t you really mean “altho with a bitter almond afterlife”?
God bless, yours in Their Hearts,
Kenneth M. Fisher
Where do these people get these wacko ideas? Evidently they cannot think with clarity. Passing themselves as professors while spewing folly out of their mouths.
Rambler: Unlike the Jebbies, McGrath is a bishop. He actually can do something about this and chooses not to. That’s why he gets singled out.
Fr. Michael, the Pope is also a Jesuit, what is he doing about all of the rot in his Order?
God bless, yours in Their Hearts,
Kenneth M. Fisher
These ‘fiends’ ghoulishly licking their chops at the idea of people killing themselves as a good and humane thing are all grinning like maniacs in their photos. Life to them is just one big cosmic joke. I’d be curious how amusing and easy it will be to make such decisions when it’s their time to face the grim reaper. God save us from shallow and inhumane pedants.
Respectfully, I understand that completely. But the Jesuits are the first persons who can do something about themselves. Culpability resides first and foremost with them. McGrath is no different from dozens of other bishops in this country who do nothing about corrupt Jesuit institutions in their juridictions. People can complain about McGrath all they want, and he is deserving, but my point is let’s not lose sight of the core problem here. That problem is the Mob, not really the ineffective local FBI. For that matter, let’s complain the Vatican doesn’t replace McGrath. The bishop problems are arguably as endemic as those of the Jesuits.
No, the Jesuits cannot any longer do anything about themselves, only to themselves and to others. They are finished, and all we’re seeing of them is the decay of a dead moldering creature stinking up the universe. The Jesuits reminds me of a dead bloated range cow we came across in the desert … At some point they explode from the gas pressure that builds up inside, and you do not want to be within a mile of such a thing. The Jesuits are even worse, infinitely worse, literally.
The more ratonal the suicide the more CULPABLE THE SIN, WHICH IS A DENIAL OF GOD AS THE LORD OF LIFE. Dignity? rather PRIDE . Eternal death is the result.
Act of Reparation to the Sacred Heart Prayer:
Adorable Heart of Jesus, glowing with love for us and inflamed with zeal for our salvation, behold us humbly prostrate before Thee to express the sorrow that fills our hearts for the coldness and indifference with which we have so long requited the numberless benefits which Thou hast conferred upon us.
It was our sins that overwhelmed Thy Heart with bitterness; it was the weight of our iniquities that pressed down Thy face to the earth in the Garden of Olives that caused Thee to expire in anguish and agony on the cross. But now, repenting and sorrowful, we cast ourselves at Thy feet and implore forgiveness.
Adorable Heart of Jesus, source of true contrition and ever merciful to the penitent sinner, impart to our hearts the spirit of penance and give to our eyes a fountain of tears that we may sincerely bewail our sins now and for the rest of our days. Oh would that we could blot them out even with our blood.
Divine Jesus, with Thee there is mercy and plentiful redemption. Deliver us from our sins; accept the sincere desire we now entertain and our holy resolutions henceforth to be faithful to Thee. Strengthen our weakness; confirm these our resolutions of amendment; and as Thy Sacred Heart is a refuge and hope when we have sinned, may it be the strength and support of our repentance so that nothing in life or death may ever again separate us from Thee. Amen.
Rambler, I’m of the opinion that the Jesuits, at least the American provinces of the order, are so corrupt that they are beyond the human possibility of internal reformation. IMHO only when they start getting booted out of dioceses will they begin serious self-examination.