The following comes from a March 8 posting by Austin Ruse on The Catholic Thing.
My wife and I sat at Mass one Christmas season at St. Peter’s Church in St. Charles, Missouri. The celebrant read a letter from the local archbishop. As he did, a lady sitting near us shook her head violently. It was only a Christmas greeting, but it brought this woman to public disapproval.
The letter was from the then Archbishop of St. Louis, Raymond Burke, now Cardinal Burke and head of the Apostolic Signatura, the supreme court of the Catholic Church.
Cardinal Burke had a rocky time in St. Louis. When it was announced he was leaving St. Louis, dissenting Catholics chortled at what they thought was his comeuppance – though the chortling turned to sorrow and even anger when his promotion to the Signatura was subsequently announced.
In his short time in St. Louis, Burke faced what all bishops have faced in recent years. He closed schools and combined parishes. Contracepting Catholics always blame the bishop, of course, when there are not enough Catholics to keep schools and parishes open.
He also had to pay from Church coffers for the sometimes criminal sexual buccaneering of homosexual priests. But the thing that seemed most to rile at least some St. Louisans was his dispute with a Polish Catholic Church.
A hundred years before, the parish had been granted a kind of independent status from the Church. It had an independent board and owned the parish property. Burke’s predecessor, Archbishop Justin Rigali tried to rein them in and then Burke tried. He removed the diocesan priests assigned to the parish, which promptly got a new priest without permission from another diocese, who ended up being excommunicated by his bishop.
That parish became a lightening rod for dissenting Catholics from St. Louis and around the country, after all here was a parish that was actually sticking it to the man and getting away with it. Burke excommunicated the parish board.
Burke also made the dissenters angry when – following the lead of Ratzinger – he excommunicated some ladies who were “ordained” priests – one even claimed to be a bishop. His letter of excommunication is exquisite, a masterpiece of canon law and reads like a document from another age. You can practically hear the long candles being smashed to the floor as the schismatics are cast from the Church.
Canonist Edward Peters put it best:
I would like to say that Abp. Raymond Burke’s excommunication of three women who recently participated in a pseudo-ordination in Saint Louis is a “text-book illustration” of how (non-judicial) excommunication is supposed to be applied in the Church today, but I can’t say that: Why not? Because Abp. Burke’s attention to juridic details and his provisions for the pastoral care of the people entrusted to his care so exceed what the textbooks teach, that it is the textbooks that must copy from him, not him from the textbooks.
Not everyone disliked Archbishop Burke, not by a long shot. Most of the faithful in St. Louis revered him and miss him to this day. The ones who loved him most and likely miss him most of all are the seminarians.
The seminary in St. Louis was packed with aspirants from across the country who wanted to be near Burke and he wanted to be near them. It is said he spent an inordinate amount of time with his seminarians and even spent one-on-one time with each of them on a regular basis.
A high-ranking Vatican official told me that, when he was a student at the North American College in Rome, then Bishop Burke went out of his way to take care of the students from small dioceses who may have been at the NAC by themselves. He regularly took them out to dinner and otherwise ministered to them.
My wife and I know him in the same way, as a soft-spoken, generous and gentle pastor.
In our first year of marriage my wife suffered through three miscarriages. Because I am from St. Louis and my wife and I do pro-life work, Archbishop Burke knew of our work and of our plight. He invited us to visit him over Christmas that year. He said he wanted to bless us with a piece of St. Gianna Molla’s wedding dress.
We met him at the bishop’s residence in the Central West End of St. Louis not far from the Cathedral Basilica of St. Louis, easily the most beautiful Church in America. He greeted us warmly and we spoke for a while about our marriage, our desire to have children, and our difficulties. He said he had a deep devotion to St. Gianna who was the last saint raised to the altars by John Paul the Great – and that she could help us.
Molla was a medical doctor who died after childbirth in 1962 after refusing an abortion or medical treatment that would have killed the unborn child. She repeatedly told her doctors to choose child’s life over her own.
Archbishop Burke had us kneel down and he blessed us with a piece of St. Gianna‘s wedding dress. Then he grinned and said, “I have done this eight times and it has worked eight times,” beaming with an intensity that only came from deep within. He wanted us to borrow the relic and venerate it in our home and then return it. Alas, though, it was his last one, all the others were already loaned out.
It turns out that at that moment Cathy was two-weeks pregnant with our first daughter Lucy. No more miscarriages. Lucy was the first of our two Gianna Molla babies. Our second daughter is named Gianna-Marie.
The next Christmas we took six-month-old Lucy to meet Archbishop Burke and we have the most wonderful picture of our tiny baby in the burly and loving arms of a true pastor and a man who has all the gifts – ecclesial, spiritual, and temporal – to be Bishop of Rome. Oremus.
Read more.
A thousand times yes!
Eternal Father, I wish to honor St. Gianna Molla and I give you thanks for all the graces You have bestowed upon her.
“A thousand times yes!” That WAS the problem….AND that is precisely what helped and enabled Obama to get re-elected.
What?
“Dare” all that you want, but Burke won’t be the next Pope.
Burke was “kicked upstairs” into his current position because he was causing too many waves as Archbishop of Minneapolis. He seemed to gt an almost perverse thrill of making threats associated with the reception of Holy Communion.
Since he’s been in Rome, what has he done? Celebrate some EF Masses in the most severe and uptight manner possible?
Anyway, it doesn’t matter. He won’t be the next pope — not with his track record, thanks be to God.
Rodda,
You are attempting to malign a very Holy Cardinal, shame on you.
I first encountered then Bishop Burke when he would call my home to get in touch with Archbishop Khai who he loved very much and the love was mutual.
May God have mercy on your poor soul,
Kenneth M. Fisher
Likely Cdl Burke was mercifully transferred out of the cesspool of the American episcopacy, and out of the reach of the pond scum that owns much of it.
If it has to be an American who is elected, please God let it be Cardinal Burke. Our Lady of America and St. Gianna Beretta Molla pray for us and the whole world.
My God, I hope not, Cardinal Burke is a far right wing reactionary who will return the church to the dark ages!!! Cardinal Burke loves to dress up in ecclesiastical attire that looks as if it came from a drag show or Halloween party!!
Thomas, only a “gay” promoter (homosexualist) talks like you do.
You just hate the light, don’t you Thomas?
Coming from you TEM I am not surprised, he purge the Church of the dissident filth, and have all your liberals running screaming from the Church……burn the rainbow flag
Well, yeah, burn the damned rainbow flag, but let’s spare the rainbow bridge … I’ve expecting to meet some great pals waiting at the far end of it with tails wagging.
A far right wing reactionary is just what is needed to get us out of the mess we are in.
Christ the King reign!
TEM,
You who venerate sodomy have a lot of nerve criticizing a Cardinal of the Church for being willing to witness his Office by dressing appropriately!
By the way, he does also wear Clericals. I don’t think he ever wears lay clothes in public. At least I never saw him in lay clothes!
May God have mercy on your compromised with sodomy soul,
Kenneth M. Fisher
The whole clothing question: They either have to wear what everyone else is wearing, or they have to wear special clothes. So, what should special clothing look like? Even though the robes they wear might have come down from some long gone era of European history, yet they were developed to express in symbols the nature of a priest. Each item of clothing symbolizes a spiritual quality. Even though I think the lace they wear is better off on a dinner table, I can put up with it since there is nothing else that would take its place. Besides in the Gospel there are passages describing special garments. Clothing is purposed to cover our “nakedness”, and this is more than merely our skin. It is also the nakedness of our soul. I heard a sermon which depicted even the more “fessed up” souls as having appearances that would floor us in disgust and terror were God to give us a momentary glimpse of them. The subject becomes one of extremely profound venture when explored academically and spiritually.
TEM, as for you homosexuals be assured that God is also in that category you call “far right reactionary”.
Cdl Burke is a radical in the sense explained by Bl John Paul II, in the way Jesus is a radical.
I am a Burkeian too. This is Holy Man who has offered the Pontifical Latin Mass far and wide whenever asked. It would be a miracle were he elected, but these things happen. In 2005 I thought Cardinal Ratzinger was too much of a straight arrow to be elected, but was fortunately wrong.
Burke is not Ratzinger. He’s not in the same league…
Rodda, you obviously have no knowledge of Burke; either that, or you do not want real Catholicism … which we can already see from all your posts. What you want is a big dress up show, sort of like when little girls play house.
Rodda, they don’t even spell their names the same … what was your point?
I’ve run into several priests who owe a lot to Cdl Burke and these are really really excellent priests.
Cardinal Burke would be a wonderful pope. Pray to the Holy Ghost that this might happen. He would soon find a way to reconcile the SSPX. He would also enforce Canon Law against abortion-loving “Catholic” politicians. There would be much consternation about Cardinal Burke as pope, but he would bring many around to the Faith. Still, too many see an American pope as requiring the selection of Cardinal Dolan, who would be a disaster to the Faith (as would Cardinal O’Malley). Nope, Burke is the guy, if the Holy Ghost consents.
First, Burke’s not going to be the next Pope…
Odd that you feel the need to take a closing shot at O’Malley and Dolan. Both are far greater churchmen than Burke will ever be.
Please enlighten us Rhodda?
I believe Cardinal Burke is in the same league with Pope BenedictXVI so is Cardinal Ragnith from Sri Lanka. There are several others as well. Cardinal Dolan and Cardinal O’Malley I don’t see it . Too me they both are disappointments.
Arby,
I guess you can’t see the forest for the trees. Do you already forget that a shot at Burke is not exactly what you did in your first post? I’m with Austin Ruse!
Rodda,
We know what you mean by “Both are far greater churchmen than Burke will ever be”. You mean that they are more modernist and would accommodate instead of “preach the Gospel in good times and in bad”!
May God have mercy on your soul,
Kenneth M. Fisher
Rodda, apparently it has not occurred to you that there is a difference between tinsel town and the Church. Your constant cry is for some sort of a splashy, big business, political machine Church with a PR network that paints it up like a Barnum and Bailey circus.
Rodda you are mislead and you are incorrect that the other two are far greater…you are not for Christ’s will but for your own ….judging from your comments
Oh my, another testy post from Arby. I’m feeling faint.
Rodda, Catholicism is the religion of Jesus, not of Hollywood. I’m trying to point this out to you because your posts indicate your religion being more of a theatrical production. Maybe you learned religion from the old movies that had nuns and priests in them. Some were good but still they were only movies.
Cdl Burke might be too authentic for consideration by the conclave.
Don’t forget how many of the cardinals were appointed by either Pope Emeritus Benedict or by his predecessor, both of whom were in favor of Catholicism for Catholics, as understood and practiced by Cardinal Burke and a handful of other American cardinals. Sadly, among them is not our area’s representative, the former scandalized and scandalous Archbishop Mahony, now Cardinal Mahony, from the long-suffering Archdiocese of Los Angeles, who swore an oath of silence at the conclave this v ery morning, not that his word means much to those of us who are grieved to have suffered under him and therefore know its worth.
As a Polish American I was horrified by his treatment of the Polish parishioners of St. Stanislaus Church in St. Louis. This church belonged to the parish and Archbishop Burke wanted them to sign it over to him. They were afraid to do this as then he could have closed the church. Because the church belonged to the people, he did not have the power to close down this particular church. Because the people did not bend to his will, he removed their priests. He thought that he could punish the people by depriving them of the Mass. They did find a priest to be a pastor for their church but he was excommunicated by Archbishop Burke. The parish has more than doubled in size since this happened and is a thriving parish but sadly because of what was done it is not a part of the Archdiocese of St. Louis. This church is a beautiful church in the “Polish Cathedral” style and is on the historic register.
The priest was excommunicated by his own bishop, not by Burke.
I was horrified that a parish council could hijack a Catholic Church. My pity is with the longtime parishioners of St. Stanislaus who can’t attend their parish anymore because the people in power at the parish would not obey their bishop.
K, if they obeyed Archbishop Burke, he could have closed down that church in a minute. With his name on the deed he could have locked the doors and sold St. Stanislaus. If the parishioners wanted to get into the church they would have been trespassing. The reason that the church is still open is because the building belongs to the parish. Since this happened, the parish community has doubled in size and is thriving.
Amen.
Polish American Catholics had long been treated badly by Irish, German and Italian descended prelates. That’s why the Polish National Catholic Church exists.
I don’t think Burke had the grace to deal with this issue in a pastoral manner. He dealt with it in a legalistic/juridical manner and he failed.
Only Polish Catholics who act badly get treated badly. Think of how well Pope John Paul II was treated. Has to do with behavior, not ethnicity. Take note before you trash people’s reputations, or turn other people into poor victims, as to what the actual facts are surrounding the situation.
I know of at least one cardinal far more worthy of bad-mouthing, since that seems to be your speciality, Arby. Can you think of anything negative to say about Cardinal Mahony, or do you only hate cardinals who are obedient to Catholicism?
I sense a gay lilt to your rants. Could I possibly be right again about you, Arby?
R.B. Rodda, I think it was an issue of pride. He held the Polish Catholics in disdain and wanted obedience from them. He looked down his nose at them and that didn’t go over well. You are correct, sadly many Irish and German bishops looked down on their Polish “subjects”. The popularity of Polish jokes and negative portrayals of Polish Catholics in the media have not helped. I don’t think the Italians have been as negative with the Polish people because a lot of people didn’t treat them fairly either.
Nonsense, Rodda. The Polish National Catholic Church is numerically a drop in the bucket compared to Polish American Catholics. You’ve got it in for Cdl Burke and you’re promoting a couple of cardinals who have never created a holy track record. Even your own posts describe these two cardinals as business executives. You’ve obviously never looked up the word “holy” which is the only reason a bishop exists … which is to be holy. Without the quality of holiness, a bishop has no meaning, no value and is worthless.
Hmmm! It seems to me R.B. Rodda that it was cardinals, a great deal of whom were of Irish, German and Italian descent who voted in Blessed Pope John Paul II.
Mark from PA –
Why should anyone embrace heresy because he is Polish?
Well Marianne, what did Polish people do to deserve Polish jokes? What did Polish people do to merit the treatment they get by some in the media. I have heard people criticize Pope John Paul II because he was one of those “Polish Catholics” some of the traditionalist groups didn’t even consider him a “valid” Pope. The Polish National Catholic Church was founded in Scranton, PA and this was partly due to problems that Polish Catholics had with Irish prelates. Today we have a bishop with Polish roots as our bishop in Scranton.
PA tell us exactly what traditional groups consider JP 2 Papacy invalid.. you again smear the Faithful
Canisius, sedavacantist groups did not consider John Paul II to be a valid Pope. I don’t think the Pius V group is loyal to the Pope. There is even a man in the US that considers himself to be Pope. These people don’t believe the Mass in English is valid either. I have read from some of these sites where it tells people not to attend the Novus Ordo Mass.
I would just point out that many of the things said above about Burke were exactly the things said about Ratzinger..
Thanks for running my piece..
Austin Ruse
Yes, they were, Austin Ruse, and thank you for your most enlightening, encouraging and uplifting article.
It would be great if Cardinal Burke were elected to the Chair of St.Peter. From what I have heard and seen from the media, his name is not mentioned. But God is incharge, and we must pray that His Holy Spirit enlighten the minds of the cardinal electors.
Thanks, Mr. Ruse, for your wonderful article. I always wondered about Cardinal Burke because some of my friends felt that he was taken to Rome in order to be ‘managed’ and others thought that he was a holy bishop who was promoted to Rome. Now I know the latter is true, and I’m delighted that he didn’t turn out to be the former. Praise God for His mercy to us.
The Boston Diocese, before and under O’Malley, is as corrupt as the Days of The Borgia. Dolan has shown, more than once, that he’ s no leader but instead an appeaser. Neither, I pray, will be the Pope. Cardinal Burke on the other hand, holding the same position that Ratzinger held before becoming Pope, I believe is made of the right stuff. We need a Pope that no matter what, if needed will lop heads off, clean the Church from top to bottom, reinstill discipline amongst the clergy and will also have to deal with an increasingly threatening pagan world. Also much needed desperately is the truth taught to us through sermons of the many sins, such as abortion, homosexual behavior, promiscuity not so much for the old but the newer generations who desperately need these truths.
I don’t think such a pope would be safe in the Vatican … look what happened to the security of BXVI’s confidential files, apparently having to do with Vatican corruption. Who will protect a pope who pushes a broom?
Whatever the Holy Ghost wills I pray for and may not the sinfulness of men disrupt that! May their free will be one that chooses the will of God and if they do not know what that is, may they take their time, reflect and pray….
HOLY HOLY HOLY is they name DEAR JESUS! OH HOW BLESSED WE ARE TO KNOW OF YOUR EXISTENCE, YOU TOOK MERCY ON US AND STILL SHOWED US YOUR WAYS…..HOW UNWORTHY WE ARE TO APPROACH YOU but because OF YOUR LOVE….we can receive you in your HOLY EUCHARIST! HELP US TO TURN AWAY FROM SIN! ABBA LORD JESUS COME NOW, WE WELCOME YOU, it is in our free will that we choose to. Halleluiah!!! OH most beautiful Holy Ghost, what a high we feel as we bow to glorify you….JESUS WE THROW OURSELVES on the floor and at your feet…..what joy it is to leave all for YOU, JESUS CHRIST, IS OUR LORD AND SALVATION! PRAISE BE THE NAME OF JESUS CHRIST!
Haily Mary full of Grace the Lord is with thee, blessed art thou amongst women and blessed is the fruit of they womb Jesus….holy MARY mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death!
AWAKE OH MY SOUL, FLESH BOW DOWN TO YOUR MASTER, die flesh die! For your great medicine is GOD! DIE FLESH….SERVE YOUR MASTER…for HIS love and mercy in unending! HIS WILL BE DONE…NOT MAN”S!
much better
Some of these comments make me think about Canon 1373. I guess Canon 1373 only applies when the Ordinary who is being discussed is a liberal.
We have a NEW POPE! POPE FRANCIS! FROM ARGENTINA… I think Miles Christi order is from there. I have never heard of him…..but hooray..our love and prayers are with our NEW POPE!
Boo hoo. Too bad. How sad.
We have an American pope — a Latin American — God bless Pope Francis from Argentina. Some say in honor of St. Francis Xavier because he is a Jesuit, and some say in honor of St. Francis of Assisi, probably both. I have had great experiences with priests from Argentina. Congratulations to the Argentinians. There is something in his name Jorge (George) for the English, Portuguese and Russians, too, as that is the patron saint of those countries.
Yes, God bless our new Pope Francis I. Thanks be to God.