Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller, prefecto of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith from 2012 to 2017, has revealed that he spent an entire day on the set of The Resurrection of Christ: Part One, the highly anticipated sequel to The Passion of the Christ that Mel Gibson has filmed in Italy, discussing the theology of the Resurrection with the filmmaker. He shared this in an interview given in Rome to OSV News, signed by its Vatican correspondent Courtney Mares.
«We talked for several hours. We spent the whole day together», explained the German prelate, aged 78. The conversation revolved around the theological and biblical meaning of the Resurrection and «the situation of Christianity, of the Christian faith, in today’s world».
Müller was not the only Church figure to visit the filming. He was joined by American Cardinal Raymond Leo Burke, evangelical preacher Franklin Graham, son of Billy Graham, and Hispanic pastor Samuel Rodriguez, president of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference. Burke described the 2004 film as a «truly monumental work, a story that deeply touched the hearts of many».
The presence of two of the most prominent cardinals from the doctrinal wing of the College of Cardinals alongside leading figures of American Protestantism speaks volumes about the audience Gibson is targeting and the cross-denominational appeal that The Passion achieved twenty-two years ago among Catholics and evangelicals.
Müller downplayed the unusual nature of his visit. The Church teaches that bishops and cardinals are successors of the apostles who appear in the film, he recalled, and «the film is not only about a historical event from two thousand years ago, but about the present Jesus Christ, the risen Lord, present as head of the Church for all believers».
The former prefect is confident that the film will help bring the central mystery of the Christian faith closer to the general public in an era when cinema and mass media shape minds. «We live in the time of mass communication, the internet, films and theatre; these modern media can be a help for everyone to approach this event, the greatest in history», he stated.
Regarding The Passion, Müller highlighted its power as «a great help for the imagination» and its personal challenge to the viewer: «What it means that Jesus suffered so much, the cross, the scourging and all those circumstances, so much for you, for you personally. He died for me».
And on the mystery that gives the new film its title: «The Resurrection is the culmination of the Christian faith. It is not just another philosophy or worldview, but a real event. The author of this real event is God the Father, who raised Jesus, his Son, who was crucified, from the dead. And this is the Resurrection, and this is a hope for all. Death is not the last word about us».
The Resurrection of Christ: Part One will premiere on May 6, 2027, the feast of the Ascension of the Lord. It is the second installment of a planned trilogy; the third, The Resurrection of Christ: Part Two, is scheduled for release on May 25, 2028.
Unlike its predecessor, filmed in Aramaic, Hebrew and Latin, the new film will be in English. Finnish actor Jaakko Ohtonen plays Jesus, replacing Jim Caviezel, and Mariela Garriga portrays Mary Magdalene. Filming lasted 134 days over more than seven months in Rome, Bari, Ginosa, Craco, Brindisi and Matera, the Basilicata city that already served as Jerusalem in 2004. Gibson has described the film, in an interview with Joe Rogan, as a «mind-blowing journey», because Jesus will descend after his death «to another realm», alluding to the descent into hell in the Creed.
As a preview, The Passion of the Christ returned to U.S. theaters between September 10 and 17 in a 4K remastered version with Dolby Atmos sound, accompanied by a first trailer of the new film and footage from the set. The original film received three Oscar nominations and grossed over $612 million worldwide, remaining for two decades as the highest-grossing R-rated film in U.S. history.
That Gibson chose to have his script reviewed by a theologian of Müller’s caliber, author of a reference dogmatic treatise and a trusted figure of Benedict XVI, is a guarantee that many faithful will appreciate in a project whose subject matter, the paschal event, allows little room for artistic license.
From infovaticana







Mel Gibson is a deeply flawed man, yet his fire for the true faith is quite astonishing. I think he’s seeking personal redemption within his work. That’s OK by me.
I haven’t been to any Hollywood made movies for almost 20 years. The last great movie I saw was the Passion of the Christ. It the best religious movie I ever saw. I am really looking forward to the Resurrection of the Christ. It promises to be a spectacular film in two parts. Right now Mel Gibson is the best epic film maker in the world today. I wish Mel Gibson would make a movie about St. Padre Pio based on an amazing book I just finished reading titled: Padre Pio And You by Mary O’Regan who’s from Ireland. You can get this book from Sophia Institute Press.
Hey, where’s the comment that’s supposed to be here?
I much prefer the outstanding, true Catholic religious films of the “Rosary Priest,” Ven. Fr. Patrick Peyton, with good, famous actors, in his Family Theater Productions. They are far better than anything that Godless, secular, sinful, money-hungry Hollywood could ever possibly produce. They reflect God’s Divine, sublime beauty, grace, truth, and great mystery and holiness. The modern, post-Conciliar, secular, humanistic-oriented world does not know the sublime, transcendent, heavenly beauty, pure holiness, and great Divine, heavenly, other-worldly Mystery and Majesty of God.
How many non-Catholics or non-practicing Catholics do you think will watch the “Rosary Priest,” Ven. Fr. Patrick Peyton?
If we want to communicate only among ourselves, sure.
Shouldn’t we be trying to reach lapsed Catholics and the lost?
I don’t like Mel Gibson, but that’s not the point.
One has claws at the end of its paws, and the other is a pause at the end of a clause.
Know the difference.
I don’t care about what others may think.
I am Catholic. I am not secular. I love good Catholic books and films from devout, faithful, gifted Catholic clergy and laity. Not Hollywood. Christ is too holy for Hollywood. I have always thought that way. If anyone is sincerely interested in Jesus Christ– go to the Catholic church, not Hollywood, to learn sbout Him. Not all will understand my viewpoint. I don’t care. Growing up, we never saw bad movies. After the Legion of Decency ended in the 1960s, and Hollywood movies were filled with gratuitous filth, violence and sin, I ended both liberal leftist perverted TV and their filthy, violent movies from my life. And so did others. Made me sick, the cardinals who saw the filthy, anti-Catholic, pervert film, “Conclave,” before their holy 2025 conclave. Not for evil Hollywood. Is nothing sacred?? That horrible, pervert film should have been banned for good.
You can find a great many of Ven. Fr. Patrick Peyton’s wonderful, award-winning, Catholic Family Theater Production films, of long ago, on YouTube. EWTN also sometimes broadcasts them, especially at Christmas and Easter. Also, the EWTN Gift Shop, Holy Cross Family Ministries store, and other Catholic religious stores, sell some of them. They are just wonderful! Highly recommend! Watch on YouTube, free!
“Difference,” how about practicing Christian charity towards your fellow commenters? If anyone has hurt your feelings, with a comment, say so plainly. We’re waiting.
If you go to Google and type in “Fr. Patrick Peyton PRAY watch film Youtube” you will see the film about the life of Ven. Fr. Patrick Peyton, “PRAY,” and you can watch (rent) the entire film for either 99 cents (Standard) or $1.99 (High Definition) TV on YouTube– or buy the film. You can also watch many other of his films for free, such as “The Life of Christ (1959),” “Life of Christ— Mysteries of the Rosary,” and Ven. Fr. Patrick Peyton himself, reciting the full Rosary, and many other wonderful films, long and short. Also, on Google, you can type “Fr. Patrick Peyton Rosary Rally San Francisco 1961” and see his historic Family Rosary Rally in Golden Gate Park in 1961, with half a million people. Wonderful!
Dear “Reply to Curious,”
You wrote, “If anyone is sincerely interested in Jesus Christ– go to the Catholic church…” Unless we first go to them with Christ, how will they know where to go to find Him? You are a Catholic with a knowledge of things Catholic. You said you don’t care what others may think. Neither do I. But, do you care about the souls of lapsed Catholics and non-Catholics? That’s what “Curious” was getting at. The Apostles didn’t sit around waiting for a lost world to join them. They went out into a lost world to save it.
Jesus promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against the Church.
Sometimes even good Catholics misunderstand that. Gates don’t move. Our Lord wasn’t talking about the gates of heaven. He was talking about the gates of hell and the Church prevailing over them.The Church moves to smash the gates of hell (and Hollywood). That’s why we need to take the truth of Jesus Christ to the world, so they can see and experience it. They aren’t likely to just somehow know the Catholic Church was founded by Jesus and join OCIA or show up at a Rosary group or Bible study. Unless we invite them! And, they’re more likely to come if they have some exposure to Jesus, a Man/the Man and God, who died and rose from the dead out of love for us.
Look at Archbishop Fulton Sheen who’s being beatified. He took the truth of the Catholic faith onto broadcast television. His show was aired on ABC and filmed and produced in New York City. Let’s move into media that reach the world and sanctify it, as Blessed Fulton Sheen did in his time. May he intercede for us and for the world.
Anonymous clergyman, I do understand the point that you and “Curious” are
making. However, too many people today, confuse the true sacred mission and evangeliztion of the Church with secular media, with young kid, self-appointed “influencers,” Hollywood secular, unholy film moguls, and unholy, secular pop stars leading unChristian lives. It is really wonderful to see the sudden interest, currently, of sincere young people going to the Catholic Church to study our religion, and become devout, sincere practicing Catholics.
Anonymous clergyman. I suppose you know, thst Mel Gibson is not eligible for reception of Holy Communion in our Church, due to personal moral and canonical impediments. He is not a practicing Catholic. He is civiilly divorced (no annulment), has had out-of-wedlock “shack-ups,” illegitimate children, and much more. Not sure what Gibson is doing currently, with religion– but years ago, he built a traditionalist church all his own, not affiliated at all with the LA Archdiocese. His father
was a strong, anti-Vatican II, anti-modern papal authority activist, and Gibson at one time, said publicly that he shared those views. I don’t think traditionalist priests of any type would want to deal with him. Nor give him Communion at Mass.
There are some very bad Catholic clerics and lay leaders at the Shrine of Our Lady of Fatima in Portugal, who refuse to take down the diabolical–and extremely inferior– “art” of “Fr.” Marko “Rapenik.” He should be serving a long prison sentence for his filthy, horrible crimes. And the Church should have Christian virtue, holiness, and decency, and remove that Satanic trash of “Rapenik,” from the holy Shrine. Regardless of the unChristian art critics– art used in diabolical, deceptive, “religious” Satanic “religious artistic” endeavors— is totally Satanic. “A man cannot serve two masters…”– either the Godless, selfish, filthy, sinful world, ruled by Satan– and dark money, power, prestige, and sin— or Jesus Christ.
I hope that the Blessed Virgin Mary does not become known as Our Lady of Rupnik.
To watch Ven. Fr. Patrick Peyton’s wonderful Catholic films of long ago, go to Google, type in “Fr. Patrick Peyton Family Theater Productions Youtube” and you will find many.of them.