“Distortions” of the sacraments that took place in churches during the coronavirus lockdown, and that are taking place as they open up again, could result in Catholics losing a sense of the sacred, says Cardinal Raymond Burke.
“The sacred in the highest sense, in the sense that we see and we experience, the sacred is Christ Himself in our midst acting to sanctify us,” he told San Diego’s Thomas McKenna of Catholic Action for Faith and Family in a May 24 interview.
Through the sacraments, Christ acts “to forgive our sins, to fortify us with the gift of his Body and Blood in the Holy Eucharist, to forgive our sins and strengthen us in serious illness,” Burke pointed out.
“But we have to understand that it’s Christ who is acting. It’s not something we invented, you know, where we can manipulate the sacred to fit our circumstances.”
However, with public Masses cancelled during the coronavirus pandemic, such manipulations have taken place, suggested Burke, a canon lawyer and well-known advocate of orthodoxy.
One such instance is the “virtual” First Holy Communion Mass planned by a parish priest in Ireland, who “gave the Sacred Hosts to their parents in advance” to take home and give to their child while watching the live-streamed Mass.
“This is very bad,” Burke said.
“These children lose all sense of the fact that the Holy Communion comes from the sacrifice in which they are taking part, united themselves to Christ.”
Another instance is priests in Italy being required to “give out Holy Communion wearing the plastic gloves and with the mask on their face.”
Burke referenced the Italian bishops’ proposal that priests could leave consecrated Hosts in plastic bags for Catholics to pick up, a practice that La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana reported in May had already been adopted in some parts of Germany.
“We can’t be putting Holy Communion, the Sacred Host, in a plastic bag, or a box to be, people taking home with them,” he said.
“These are distortions of the sacramental sign. And they simply can’t be permitted.”
Burke also made reference to an American bishop’s short-lived proposal that nurses administer oils for the anointing of the sick to coronavirus patients so priests wouldn’t be exposed to the disease.
The Church has always understood that only a priest can administer extreme unction “because it’s Christ who comes to the sick person, and prays over the sick person, and anoints the sick person could give them strength in their illness,” Burke said.
“We pray always for physical healing, but we pray at the same time for that spiritual strength to embrace whatever illness the person has and to unite it to the suffering of Christ,” he said.
“And to suggest that this could be done by a person other than a priest is a manifest loss of faith in the sacrament itself.”
Burke said he fears that the cancellation of public Masses has caused an erosion of Catholics’ belief in the centrality of the Eucharist and of their obligation to attend Mass on Sunday.
He has read reports of “even good people who’ve said, well, in a certain way they preferred taking part in Mass at home, in the comfort of their home, with the television,” the cardinal observed.
“But this isn’t participating in Holy Mass. It’s a holy thing to watch the Mass and to be in awe of it, but it’s not participation. Christ isn’t present on the television screen. And He’s not in your home by that means,” he said.
Catholics who know what the Mass is will return “very wholeheartedly to fulfilling the Sunday obligation to assist at Holy Mass,” Burke observed.
“But for those who may not be so catechized, I fear very much that the easy way in which the churches were closed, and (that) it was said that the bishops were dispensing the people from the Sunday Mass obligation for this long period of time, could give the people the impression that Sunday Mass is just one more practice in the church, which the bishop can dispense.”
Indeed, Archbishop Víctor Manuel Fernández of La Planta, Argentina, a papal ghostwriter and confidant of Pope Francis, suggested in an April interview that the obligation to go to Mass on Sundays and Holy Days “is not indispensable” and “is something that could fall.”
But the Church does not have the authority to drop the obligation to go to Mass on Sunday, which is a commandment from God, Burke pointed out. When it has been impossible during the current crisis for the faithful to attend Mass, the obligation does not bind them, but the obligation remains.
“It’s not correct to say that the bishop dispenses the faithful from the obligation of Sunday Mass, because Sunday Mass is a response to the Third Commandment. This is divine law,” he emphasized.
It’s clear in the wake of what coronavirus pandemic lockdowns have wrought, or brought to light, that Catholics need to be catechized on core beliefs of their faith.
“We’re going to have to restore very much the catechesis with regard to the Eucharist, and the whole sense of the Sunday Mass obligation, because I can see that there’s been a certain erosion,” he said.
Burke also criticized the Vatican’s secret accord with China, noting that bishops faithful to the Church who have persevered as members of the underground Church despite persecution are now being asked to sign an oath of loyalty to the Communist Party of China, which regards the only acceptable religion as China itself.
The above comes from a May 27 story on LifeSiteNews.
Cardinal Burke is ever the voice of reason and we should be thankful for his vocation! He is willing to speak up when other bishop go limp and it has cost him. Ever true, he continues to lead and bring the faithful to the truth. Pray for his safety and security as he fulfills his mission. :)
What has it cost him? He seems pretty comfortable to me. And the more he throws red meat to the traddies the more stories and adulation he gets.
Start with the highly unusual move by Pope Francis to remove the Cardinal from the position of prefect of the Apostolic Signature (the Vatican’s Supreme Court) without reason or assignment to a another position of comparable responsibilities. Unceremoniously demoted and openly called an enemy of the pope – which he is not – that’s not so comfortable Kev.
There have long been TV ‘Mass for Shut-ins [and I bet before that radio]. While the liturgical calendar says we are in ordinary time, the COVID situation requires certain actions for public health. Fortunately we have the technology to create a temporary substitute to a traditional First Communion. A young child eagerly awaits their entrance to the Eucharist. I say avail ourselves of the technology. Return to the traditional when the health situation permits.
I’ve adjusted to this new normal and kind of like it even though it was weird at first. I’m safe from infection at home and can watch the Mass when I feel like it, even pause it to take care of something else like if the phone rings or I get a message. Then get back to it. I don’t think Cardinal Burke is seeing the silver lining here for so many Catholics, and we shouldn’t be afraid of how technology can make Mass reach out to more people at more times. I kind of hope the Sunday dispensation is in place for a long time. Yeah, I’ll go to physical Mass at the church every now and then to get Communion, but TV Mass at home has a lot of advantages, and it’s the same homily and music I’d hear if I were in the pews so what’s the big deal?
Sports are better on TV. Better view, more comfortable and convenient. Same with streamed Mass.
And lounging bed is even more comfy…how long until you quit Mass altogether?? Sacrifice Jessica.
I love Cardinal Burke and it is kind of him to do interviews but there are people on the internet who misuse his quotes and exploit him. Pray for him and for the conversion of sinners. Pray the prayer to St. Joseph.
What a great teaching moment for these kids! That the sacrifice of the Mass on the altar is not the same thing as receiving Communion which isn’t even necessary for the huge graces that flow from the sacrifice. The source and summit of our faith is not receiving Communion. It’s the confection of the Sacrament in the first place.
Say what… “That the sacrifice of the Mass on the altar is not the same thing as receiving Communion which isn’t even necessary for the huge graces that flow from the sacrifice.” I believe this comment is why many people need to go back to learning about your faith because this is a misrepresentation of Cardinal Burke’s words…
“Through the sacraments, Christ acts “to forgive our sins, to fortify us with the gift of his Body and Blood in the Holy Eucharist, to forgive our sins and strengthen us in serious illness,” Burke pointed out.
Receiving the Eucharist is the culmination of the sacrifice and cannot be separated from it.
The Cardinal is correct. The virtual Mass is not the same as being in the church actually participating in the sacrament. Many of the televised Masses ask us to pray for spiritual communion, but it is not the same as the “real thing.” I think most people understand that and will return to church when the ban on large gatherings is lifted. Who knows, however, when that will be since the number of hospitalizations is mounting and deaths skyrocketing. God will tell us when it is safe to return. In the Sacramento area, the Bishop has announced that churches may open on June 8th for those who wish to attend, up to b100 at each Mass.
Palpably Papabile.
If Jesus wants people to go back to Mass and the churches to open up again, he should rid the world of the virus. We’re told he’s got the whole world in his hands, right? So why doesn’t he do anything to help? So until God stops the virus, he shouldn’t be disappointed that people are staying home instead of going to church to worship him. Iron-clad reasoning right there. I wonder what Cardinal Burke would say to that.
I come here for the comedy gold of the non existently catechized like Kevin here. Psst. Kevin… google God’s permissive will. You’re welcome.