The California insurance commissioner is clarifying that insurance coverage on double mastectomies for gender dysphoric females is not “cosmetic” but “reconstructive,” and classifying normal breast tissue as “abnormal structures of the body caused by congenital defects.”
The move paves the way for more minor girls who identify as something other than their biological sex to undergo breast amputation.
In a Dec. 30 letter from General Counsel and Deputy Commissioner Kenneth Scholl under the banner of Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara, the state agency clarified that existing law says health insurance providers may not deny “male chest reconstruction surgery for female-to-male patients” solely on the basis of age. The letter was in response to the San Diego-based TransFamily Support Services, which had inquired about the criteria.
The department is instructing health insurance companies to “consider a patient’s specific clinical situation to determine actual medical necessity based on evidence-based standards of care.”
The letter referenced specific sections of legal code that require insurance coverage of surgeries that “improve function” or “create a normal appearance, to the extent possible” and forbid discrimination “on the basis of an insured’s or prospective insured’s actual or perceived gender identity, or on the basis that the insured or prospective insured is a transgender person.”
Whereas the surgeries were once referred to as “cosmetic,” the state agency now refers to them as “reconstructive” and also categorizes physically healthy breasts as “abnormal structures of the body caused by congenital defects, developmental abnormalities, trauma, infection, tumors, or disease.”
Maria Keffler, co-founder of the recently-formed Partners for Ethical Care, said in an email to The Christian Post Monday that she finds this particular change in language an “unethical, predatory, and despicable attempt to even more viciously abuse children via gender ideology.”
“By circumventing parental consent in order to medicalize children without any minimum age restriction, the California Department of Insurance, whose very letterhead claims to ‘Protect, Prevent, and Preserve’, does exactly the opposite,” Keffler said.
The letter cites as authoritative the standards of care from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, she pointed out, but even WPATH currently states that the evidence base is not sufficient to predict the long-term outcomes of completing a gender role transition in early childhood.
“WPATH also cites that 73-88% of children who suffer gender dysphoria will align with their birth sex if allowed to pass through puberty naturally. Scholl, the California Department of Insurance, and the gender industry are propagating, participating in, and profiting from unchecked savagery against our nation’s children,” Keffler asserted.
Supporters of the move said the change is yet another win against a form of discrimination within the medical arena.
“The state of California has always led the way on issues of equality, and this legal opinion takes a much-needed stand to protect the rights of California’s LGBTQ residents, regardless of age,” said California Assemblyman Evan Low, a Democrat from the Bay area and chair of the Legislative LGBTQ Caucus, in a statement last week….
The above comes from a Jan. 5 story on The Christian Post.
The left in general and the Democrat Party in particular continue to assault and mangle the plain meaning of words and continue to ignore biological science in their evil effort to undo everything good and true. Thirty years ago, just about everything being advocated by Democrats today would have been considered insane and unthinkable because they utterly and completely defy rationality and facts. It worsens and worsens, yet God does… nothing to help his people. Bishops are ineffectual and even cozy up to the irrational Democrat leaders; some even support their aims. It’s going to get worse still with Democrats now controlling the federal government. Get ready for the Equality Act to become law. Get ready for mainstreaming transgenderism even beyond what this insurance regulation requires. It worsens and worsens, yet God does… nothing to help his people. Many, many committed Catholics are perplexed and disillusioned; many feel like there’s no solid ground to stand on. Prayers seem to have no effect. Suffering for the faith and for truth seem not to be worthwhile. The wicked prosper and laugh at God’s little ones. Being faithful to the teachings of the Church result in lost friendships, strained family relations, diminished career opportunities or loss of job, and there’s no spiritual or material consolation provided by God to compensate. It worsens and worsens, yet God does… nothing to help his people.
Kevin, I understand how you feel. Right or wrong, many feel the same way. God works in His own way, in His own time. That shouldn’t stop us from hoping and praying.
@ Anon -4:30 p.m. – This is a compassionate response, and one I think the Good Lord would want us to give. Thank you.
Kevin T…..I too understand exactly how you feel. I’m yelling at God all day today saying “where are you” but like Anon the answer I receive are the words of my late sister who trusted God even though she would die an early age…”God is in charge.” We can’t know the mind of God and understand his reasoning for this fraudulent election with the election of the most pro-abortion, anti-religious liberty and pro-gender confusion party ever. We have to trust Him and let Him use us to challenge this “culture of death”. But never give up. He hasn’t given up on us.
@ Ronnie – Yes, and I keep telling myself that each day to never give up. I identify with and have compassion for all of those who struggle to feel the presence of God in this chaos. We just need to keep praying for one another and lend an ear when we sense someone is suffering.
Kevin T.’s continued “lamentations” are not helping, sorry to say. Just what does he mean that “God does nothing to help his people”? God didn’t do anything? Wrong. Kevin T., God has sent His Son, He sent and continues to send His Holy Spirit for His people, He gave His Church the sacraments so that His people can receive His graces to cope with things and not lose faith. God didn’t promise you that there will be no trouble; God didn’t promise you that the Democrats will never be in power; God didn’t promise you that the world will be perfect according to your preferences. Your “lamentations” are sounding more and more like the complaints of an entitled person who thinks God owes him HIs help whenever. Well, Kevin T., God is not a vending machine who just automatically pours whatever favors you want from Him just because you said your prayers. Be wary people of the attitude that questions God so boldly because He can very well turn around and ask your conscience, “What did I do? Why, I put you in my earth and sent you. What did you do about it?”
you pontificate about things you have no knowledge about. everyone sees it and thinks it.
Hey, jon– if you say you are a “Christian”– where is your Christian charity, love, humility, compassion, sympathy, empathy, listening to and understanding of your fellow Catholics on this website?? Where is the Holy Spirit in your spiritual life, to give to you these important graces? According to Christ, there is only one place to criticize others — when people act evil, like the Pharisees. That’s all.
Where is my charity Anonymous at 11:15pm writes. Anonymous, informing and admonishing the ignorant is an act of charity. Why else do you think I am here reading your comments? Do you think I enjoy that?I am informing and admonishing those who see fit to somehow question God and presume that He does nothing for His people. Such lack of reverence for God is shameful.
I’m pretty confident that St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Alphonsus Ligouri and many others would consider conceit, arrogance and smugness to be sinful.
I agree Shirley: There is nothing more conceited, arrogant, and smug than to tell God, “You’re not helping.”
“So faith, hope, love remain; but the greatest of these is love.”
(I Cor. 13) Good idea, for all believers to regularly re-read St. Paul’s famous Epistle on Charity.
No self awareness.
jon every specter of hell is being unleashed in America. It’s not unbecoming to wonder and ask and lament, “What’s God doing?” or “Where’s God?” This good society is collapsing, becoming totalitarian, is actively purging Christian morality, objective truth, and values from the public square, and the Church and many faithful Catholics will suffer, and great darkness will come upon the earth without American goodness backed by power and might. There’s no help from God. He has done nothing to help as this society falls into moral and political disarray and in which government and corporations and academia, and even some bishops (and not just in America), are aligning with evil. I’ve not heard one helpful thing said from a Catholic cleric. It’s as if they realize their own impotence or they secretly desire what’s happening without wanting the true faithful to know their wishes. God needs to intervene to save his people, his bride, his Church whom he loves. It hasn’t even gotten really bad yet, but I can see where it’s going if God doesn’t do something to stop it. Before long, faithful Catholics will be shut out of gainful employment or they’ll have to keep their values secret in order not to be locked out of the tech and information and commerce and banking networks controlled by Google, Apple, Twitter, Amazon and so forth. Eventually posting on a site like this or your search history could cause someone to lose a job or be blacklisted for supporting Catholic faith and morality. That’s why there are so many anonymouses who post here. Anger at the devolving situation and angry questions addressed to God are completely justified. And the kick to the head? Fraudulent Catholics Joe Biden and Nancy Pelosi are going to usher in the persecution of the Church, and most bishops will say nothing. How’s that for providence?
Kevin T’s presumptions are off-base and his “lamentations” are indeed unbecoming. Firstly, his presumptions about the Catholic clergy in this situation is way off-the-mark and malicious. That they “secretly desire what’s happening”? None of the priests I know desires what’s happening. Such a negative presumption about the Catholic clergy is not only unbecoming, it is distasteful and ridiculous. Secondly, his “lamentations” continue to be unhelpful and unbecoming if not blasphemous. For a mere mortal to “judge” God, that He is not helping, is just loathsome. Just who does he think he is? God’s judge? Wow. Talk about (to use Shirley’s word) having “no self-awareness.”
Kevin T. needs to work on his faith I daresay. And people, if you get into the habit of being of a negative and critical mind about the clergy of the Church, you’re on a sure road to being of a negative and critical mind about God Himself. And being of that mindset is hell on earth. Beware people. Beware.
Please read Matthew chapter 10.
Kevin T.– I am a different “Anon.” All through the ages, if you look at history– people have been saying the same thing, when calamities hit– “where is God?” Our current times in modern-day America– a very rich, blessed, democratic society, with lots of opportunities– is filled with previously-unheard-of modern conveniences, scientific wonders, easy answers to many things, and lots of options that our ancestors never dreamed of! Before the modern era, people were more acquainted with putting up with many inconveniences, suffering, hardship, and an early death. Many people also developed sour attitudes, as life was so hard, and so full of problems, no natter what– rich or poor!
Kevin T. — it is only in the recent era of post-Vatican II, that the Catholic Church has changed from emphasizing the importance of the spiritual life– striving for Eternal Life, with God– to extreme valuing of humanistic happiness, success, and comfort in earthly life. There used to be a recognition, that real life begins– at Death, in Heaven, not on earth! Earth is only a temporary place for us “pilgrims” to prepare our souls for life with God, in Heaven! The Church did not view temporal, worldly things, such as politics, as very important. You were not supposed to be “worldly,” nor put much importance on your life, good or bad– you were supposed to offer up to Jesus all your sufferings, in union with His– suffering was a great opportunity for man’s purification. Our suffering is caused by “Adam’s Fall,” and Original Sin. That is why we are separated from God– why God seems so far from us.
I believe in being humanistic, too, in the right balance, as a Catholic — and am deeply thankful to God for my life, and for all my blessings, from God! But always with my eyes on Heaven, as a Catholic! To prepare for our Eternal Life in Heaven, is very important! I believe we must all be reasonable, and cheerfully and humbly accept the things we cannot change— and above all, seek to lead a good life, according to God’s purposes.
And the courage to change the things I can & of course, the wisdom to know the difference.
Ronnie– Yes! The “Serenity Prayer” is excellent!
For anyone who wishes to understand the dynamics of how the West has arrived at such insanity, I strongly recommend the following book, “The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self” by Carl Trueman.
A book review can be found at:
https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2020/11/29/the-story-of-the-rise-triumph-and-nightmare-of-the-modern-self/
The lunatics have taken over the asylum. God help us!
Bunch of women hating misogynists…I can’t for the life of me understand how lesbians can support the Pride agenda as it has been overrun by chauvinistic homosexuals and anti-woman zealots…
A significant number of lesbians oppose the trans agenda.
The Federalist had an article, “Why Other Queers are Stuffing Lesbians Back into the Closet.” It’s linked below if you’re interested:
https://thefederalist.com/2020/12/10/why-other-queers-are-stuffing-lesbians-back-in-the-closet/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=742001&refcd=742001&utm_source=RevelantResources&seid=10455135
And, it seems all feminists would oppose such assaults on girls and women. It is perplexing that they don’t.
This is so tragic.
Mark once you grant “rights” to one set of deviants, society must grant them to all deviants.
The above reads in part: “. . . sections of legal code that require insurance coverage of surgeries that “improve function” or “create a normal appearance”,
I have wrinkles and my face is sagging. Therefore, we should require insurance companies to pay for my face lift surgery to “create a normal appearance”. Not to do so is discriminatory. Is there an attorney willing to take my case?
Perhaps on one side of the building there is a woman who wants her breasts removed, and on the other side of the building there is a woman who wants bigger breasts. Can they transplant breast tissue from one woman to another?
Good question. I have always wanted to shove part of my hip area shoved up to my chest area, would be great if they could do that. (laughter.) Nevertheless, larger hips are great for birthing. Makes it much easier. Had no difficulty having my children. Had them almost before the doctors got there.
I think it is important for children to be taught, to accept themselves and others, exactly as they are. I once had a close friend, in college, who was Jewish, and blessed to be a brilliant and successful girl– a straight-A student. But strangely, she badly wanted a “nose job” from a plastic surgeon. She was a beautiful girl, and no one could figure out why she wanted to fix her nose. Her parents thought it to be wrong and wouldn’t pay for it. So she saved up her own money, and had the surgery done. Lo and behold– not one person noticed what she had done — until she finally revealed it, as no one had noticed, nor given her a compliment. When she told us all, everyone was so confused. Even her parents and fiance could not tell a difference. So, everyone laughed– she had always been loved for who she was, as a person. And now her parents were thrilled, she was marrying a good, observant Jewish boy. It is who you really are, that counts! Self-acceptance, and figuring out a good adjustment to things in your life, is very important.
The crucible for silver, and the furnace for gold, but the tester of hearts is the Lord.
Proverbs 17:3
And, this atrocity, this child abuse, is from the same people who tell us we must “follow the science,” even when there is not a shred of scientific evidence for more than two sexes or genders or that one’s sex can actually be changed.
Because the left do nothing but lie.