Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco recently weighed in on the illicit episcopal consecrations that the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) carried out July 1, emphasizing the need to increase access to the Traditional Latin Mass to support Catholics with an attachment to this liturgy in the wake of the schism.
The archbishop said in a July 10 X post that the consecration of four SSPX bishops “manifests a growing lack of trust that has been simmering for a very long time.”
The SSPX carried out the consecrations in Switzerland after months of controversy surrounding the plan. The Vatican warned doing so would constitute a schismatic act, because it lacked papal approval. The situation mirrored the SSPX episcopal consecrations that took place in 1988, when SSPX founder Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre ordained four new bishops without Pope St. John Paul II’s approval. In the years since, the SSPX has continued to raise theological concerns regarding documents from Vatican II, while maintaining a status of canonical irregularity as referenced by Pope Benedict XVI and celebrating the TLM.
After the July 1 consecrations, the Vatican declared that SSPX priests and lay people who formally adhere to the SSPX are in schism. A number of diocesan bishops across the U.S. have since instructed the local faithful not to attend SSPX parishes.
Archbishop Cordileone said in his X post, “Let us pray that an ardent effort toward sincere and honest dialogue will soon start up, and that easier access to the Traditional form of the Mass will be available to our people, so they will not feel as if they are constrained to seek spiritual nourishment outside of the family in union with Rome.”
Archbishop Cordileone had also expressed support earlier that day for expanding access to the TLM, in reply to an article in the National Catholic Register regarding TLM access.
“We need more access to the traditional Latin Mass for the faithful but also more reverent Novus Ordo Masses inspired by the tradition,” Archbishop Cordileone stated.
Pope Benedict XVI issued an apostolic letter in 2007 called Summorum Pontificum expanding access to the TLM. In an accompanying letter to bishops, he explained that the TLM and the Novus Ordo “can be mutually enriching,” emphasizing that the two editions of the Roman Missal do not contradict one another. He also cited being motivated to issue Summorum Pontificum out of desire for internal reconciliation after the 1988 SSPX situation.
In 2021, Pope Francis issued an apostolic letter called Traditionis Custodes that heavily restricted the celebration of the TLM, saying that the decision comes after consulting the then-Congregation (now Dicastery) for the Doctrine of the Faith regarding the pursuit of ecclesial communion.
The National Catholic Register article that Archbishop Cordileone replied to on X focuses on comments made by Pope Benedict XVI’s longtime personal secretary, Archbishop Georg Gänswein, regarding Traditionis Custodes and TLM restrictions.
Archbishop Gänswein, who is now apostolic nuncio to the Baltic States, told Nico Spuntoni of Il Giornale, an Italian daily, that he saw Pope Benedict XVI experience “pain in his heart” from reading Traditionis Custodes, according to the National Catholic Register.
Archbishop Gänswein said Pope Francis “made a mistake without realizing it” when issuing Traditionis Custodes.
The archbishop told Spuntoni in the interview, conducted just days after the SSPX ordinations, that he believes this is the opportune moment “to lift those restrictions and move beyond the setback represented by that text.”
From Zeale.co







I fully agree with Abp. Ganswein and Abp. Cordileone. Pope Benedict’s “Summorum Pontificum” is the best plan.
“He Who Believes Is Not Alone”.
I found Archbishop’s Gainswein’s book most enlightening. I often felt sorry for him, being caught in between the retired pope and the newer one. The book mentions how Pope Benedict, as Cardinal Ratzinger, asked Pope John Paul II to release him to go back to his beloved Bavaria to write in peace, and how Benedict was too frail as he got older to keep up with all that was required from him.
Summorum Pontificum was flawed by an inherent tension: namely claiming without theological or liturgical or historical justification that the Roman Rite could have two simultaneous liturgical forms called “ordinary” and “extraordinary”. There was no precedent and no justification for claiming that a single rite could have more than one form in simultaneous use; it was a legal fiction.
There is no place in the Church for the TLM anymore, as I have said. Vatican 2 mandated that the liturgy be reformed. The Roman Church reformed the liturgy in obedience to the Council, and now Catholics in obedience are required to adhere to the reformed Mass. Celebrating the TLM directly rejects Vatican II’s call for liturgical reform. The TLM is no longer an adequate liturgical expression of the Roman Church’s faith. It was a phase in the Roman Church’s liturgical life, and it has been replaced by a subsequent phase with its own liturgy. In the future there may well be a further revision of the liturgy, which will entail leaving the current Missal behind.
Fix the lousy celebrations of the reformed Mass, by all means. The Church does not celebrate Mass well hardly anywhere. But the 2008 Missale Romanum Editio Tertia is the only missal that should be used for Mass in the Roman Rite. That is what is demanded in the Church’s post-Conciliar era.
Simply not so. The Roman Rite is not as uniform as you claim. Legitimate variants exist and have existed for centuries, the most recent being the Anglican Use following another initiative by Pope Benedict XVI. These can coexist peacefully if given a chance. In fact I welcome the richness of legitimate diversity in Catholic liturgy (setting aside clown masses and the like). All these forms of the Latin Rite represent living history that we’d be foolish to throw away. They also (in common with Eastern rites) provide points of reference for us to compare our “ordinary form” liturgies with. If something seems off the rails, compare it to other historical rites; if no one ever did it in the Eastern or Western liturgical rites (for example, altar girls), it’s probably a bad idea.
There have always been different variations and regional customs, oncorpirated into the Roman Rite, all Vatican-approved. We also have 23 different Eastern Catholic churches in union with Rome, each has their own governance and rite. We also have the Anglican Rite for Anglican converts. And the weird Amazonian Rite, too, with its new Mayan Missal. The Roman leaders and early Christians wisely knew that each region and nationality needs to include some liturgical variations and local customs, to accommodate their needs. Pope Benedict was a world-class scholar, and may oneday be honored as a “Doctor of the Church.” It is unwise to put yourself above such a great scholar and pope. Instead, ask questions, and seek answers that are accurate. Vatican II has many unresolved problems and ambiguities, which the Church must someday deal with. And no– the creation of the Novus Ordo Missae text did not reflect the Council Fathers’ liturgical document, “Sacrosanctum Concilium.” The “interim Mass” of the mid-1960s was much better. There are many problems in the Vatican II era– many churches are empty. Many Mass-goers also are no longer Catholic, and many no longer believe in the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist.
Long before the birth of Christ, the Roman Empire was made up of many different regions. When Rome conquered a country and added it to the Empire, they realized the importance of those people to be allowed to keep their own ways of life, religion, and customs. Yet the people also adopted important Roman ways, paid taxes, and received Roman protection, and all the rights and privileges of Roman citizenship. When the Roman Empire was converted to Christianity, missionaries adopted this same strategy, when converting peoples of different regions and countries to Christianity.
“Greg The Geologist” and “Reply” are simply mistaken. For example, the comparison to the Anglican Use doesn’t quite hold up canonical or structural weight.
The Anglican Use was an act of corporate reunion. It brought an outside community (with its own history, canon law, and rite) into the Catholic Church, preserving a distinct, centuries-old Anglican patrimony under its own unique canonical structure (the Personal Ordinariates).
By contrast, the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) is not an external tradition being integrated. The priests and faithful of the former Ecclesia Dei communities like your beloved FSSP (and prior to their schismatic act, the beloved SSPX) already belong to the Latin Church. Summorum Pontificum was not the recognition of a distinct rite being grafted into the Latin Rite Church, but an internal pastoral accommodation allowing Latin Rite priests to use an older missal of their own rite.
I daresay, “Summorum” can be rightly interpreted as a temporary accommodation to those still attached to the former rite, until such a time when the mandates of the last Ecumenical Council are fully implemented. After that, the Church—as one body—is moving forward with UNITY using a single form of the one Roman Latin Rite. And this is where Pope Leo is gently leading the Church, with his repeated appeals to unity.
Mixing an internal disciplinary dispensation/accommodation (for the beloved FSSP) with the corporate reception of an entirely separate historical tradition (for the Anglicans) creates a false equivalence.
Furthermore, bringing up the Amazonian adaptation or the Mayan innovations actually undermines “Reply’s” point. Those are examples of inculturation within the post Conciliar framework authorized by the current hierarchy, not the preservation of pre-conciliar books.
Finally, appealing to Pope Benedict XVI’s immense academic scholarship misses the nature of governance in the Church. Liturgical discipline is a matter of authority, not scholarship. A reigning Pope possesses the supreme authority to regulate the liturgy for the sake of unity, which is exactly why Pope Francis by abrogating Summorum has correctly redirected the Latin Church to move forward as one body under a single, unique expression of the Roman Rite.
It is simply a mistake to say “hey, we have the Anglican Use, the Ambrosian Rite, the Eastern Catholic Rites, so why not keep the TLM”, without carefully looking at the distinct history of the communities using those rites and why they are incorporated into the Church.
You make the Roman Empire sound so genteel and liberal.
“Summorum Pontificum was flawed …” Would you display such hubris to his face if Benedict were still alive?
Pope Benedict was an intellectual who loved theological and philosophical debates. He would have met criticism of SP with calm and collected objectivity. He would have listened and given due consideration to objections. Pope Benedict was not a huffy puffy, easily offended, intellectually mediocre reactionary like some posters on this site are.
Besides, even trads have admitted that SP’s arrangement of allowing both forms of the Roman Rite to coexist was strange. They didn’t question it much because it gave them what they wanted: unfettered access to the TLM.
SP was Benedict’s attempt to bring the SSPX back into communion with Rome and to prevent more trads from defecting to the SSPX. It was also an attempt to bring the novus ordo Mass back into conformity with tradition in its celebration. Unfortunately, SP had the unintended and unforseen effect of emboldening and entrenching anti-Vatican 2 groups in the church. That’s why Pope Francis rescinded SP.
The Roman Empire was a great success. It started as a Republic, which lasted from about 509-27 B.C. The Empire, ruled by emperors, lasted from about 27 B.C. to 476 A.D. In 287 A.D., the Roman Empire was first split into two administrative halves, East and West, because it was too big for one emperor to rule. The Eastern Roman Empire — or Byzantine Empire– lasted another 1,000 years, until it fell to the (Muslim) Ottoman Empire in 1453, when they captured the capital city of Constantinople. Do you think our Christian Western civilization could also someday fall to the Muslims? Scary.
” Pope Benedict was not a huffy puffy, easily offended, intellectually mediocre reactionary like some posters on this site are.” You exalt yourself by your rash judgement of Benedict XVI and demean others who take offence at your treatment of the man and your perfunctory analysis of the Pope Francis’ reversal of SP. I find this hard to bear.
Jon and Alien find fault with one of the greatest 20th century theologians– Pope Benedict. The Vatican II era has been one of the greatest periods of crisis in the entire 21 centuries of Church history. Much work needs to be done, especially to save the sinking ship of the Catholic Church in Western Civilization.
I’m afraid the proposal that the beloved SSPX’s recent schismatic act is an opportune moment to make access to the Extraordinary Form easier misses the mark. That easier access is not what the global Latin Church truly needs.
What the Latin Church needs, at least in the American Church, and perhaps in European ones too, is a more revered, dignified celebration of the Ordinary Form. Put your energy on that, please.
Now the Church in Africa and Asian is growing tremendously without the apparent “liturgical needs” of some American Catholics. They are growing with the Ordinary Form that speaks to their culture.
Remember that people: this pining for the Extraordinary Form seems to be centered only in some parts of Western society.
I don’t give a flying fig about the SSPX or the TLM. I don’t care! You, however, keep hammering at “people” here as though we’re all fundamentalist extremists in need of a good smacking. Don’t counter-point every comment to prove how smart you think you are. Try to encourage and show support to other Catholics, if you’re capable.
Greg the Geologist — please know that you have my “thumbs-up” although it didn’t work. Thank you for your comment.
There is a difference between “use” and “rite”. The Anglican “use” is within the fold of the Roman “rite”. There is no such thing as the “Anglican Rite” nor “Amazonian Rite”. There is also a Zaire use within the Roman Rite.
Eastern Catholic rites are their own liturgical forms, separate and distinct from the Roman Rite.
Within the Roman Rite there are indeed various uses, or authorized slight adaptations made to the Roman Rite. Such uses maintain a structural unity with the Roman Rite, as they are adaptations of the reformed Roman Rite, not different rites.
The TLM is not a use of the Roman Rite. It is a prior version of the Roman Rite. It is the unreformed Roman Rite. The Roman Rite has a new, current version: the third edition of the current Roman Missal, promulgated after the Second Vatican Council and the liturgical reforms it mandated. It makes no logical sense to maintain both the superseded and the superseding forms of the Roman Rite simultaneously.
Benedict made an error without realizing it. First, in promulgating Summorum Pontificum. Second, by resigning, which allowed Francis to ascend.
Alien and errors: Neither of you can possibly ever dare to compare your laymen’s armchair knowledge and opinions to a great Catholic theologian, scholar and pope like Pope Benedict. You also have no fluency at all with the use of theological language, tradition, European Catholic thought, foreign languages of great Catholic theologians, and potential meanings compensated for or adjusted in translations to English. All of this material has its origins in a far different culture than America. Pope Benedict was a world-class European theologian, scholar, and professor.
The ancient Anglican tradition is based on the Sarum Psalter, of the medieval era. It was created by St. Osmund, a French Norman bishop of Salisbury (called “Sarum” in Latin), combining French Norman rites with Anglo-Saxon worship, after the 1066 Norman conquest of England.This was the main style of local Catholic worship in England until the Reformation. It contained the Divine Office, prayers, and hymns in Latin, and lovely, unique Sarum Chant– a localized, simpler form of Gregorian Chant. During the English Reformation, the Sarum Psalter influenced the changes to the Anglican Church and its Book of Common Prayer. Sarum Chant was re-shaped into English Anglican Chant for use by the Church of England. All of this great Anglican Patrimony, or heritage, was used in the creation by Pope Benedict, in 2009, of the style of worship, of the Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter. The great, ancient, beautiful and holy Sarum Psalter is a great treasure of the Anglican heritage. Anglican Chant, based on the medieval Sarum Chant, adapted beautifully to the English janguage, is easy to sing. Anglican Ordinariate priests face ad orientem.
In 1549, Archbishop Thomas Cranmer, the Archbishop of Canterbury and a “Protestantized” ally of King Henry VIII, took the daily monastic Divine Office and combined and simplified it into just two Offices, Morning and Evening Prayer. Cranmer removed prayers to saints and added more Scriptural readings. This material was published in the first Book of Common Prayer for the English people, in 1549. Anglican Chant, utilized in Morning and Evening Prayer, is lovely, beautifully crafted for the English language, and is very easy to sing. Much of this Anglican Patrimony was incorporated into the new Catholic Anglican Ordinariate.
There are some lovely religious traditions, prayers, devotions, special Feast Days, etc. in many Catholic cultures, worldwide. In San Fancisco, we have the French National Church, Notre Dame des Victoires, with a French Mass and devotions for the French; and the Italian Natiional Church, Sts. Peter and Paul, which has an Italian Mass and devotions, and also, a Mass and devotions for the Chinese; St. Patrick’s Church, which serves many Filipinos, with a monthly Tagalog Mass and religious devotions, etc. Their main Sunday Mass, which they prefer, is a Latin Novus Ordo Mass. All of these churches also have English Novus Ordo Masses. Star of the Sea has a Latin Tridentine Mass, the Cathedral has monthly Latin TrIdentine Masses, and a Spanish Mass on Sundays, as well as English Novus Ordo Masses. Plus, the city has much more!
I’m one of the “intellectually mediocre reactionaries” who would like you to say that to my face.
Some Catholics are deeply personal about the Mass and liturgies they favor— or dislike for various reasons. Of course a beautiful, holy, reverent Mass with a beautiful liturgy, well-done, lifts the heart and mind to God. (Very rare these days sadly.) However the Mass and liturgy in general is formal, structured for public Divine worship for the millions. And it belongs to no one except the Pope and Vatican– who provide materials for their approved Masses and liturgies. It is not ours. We should attend Mass at rhe church of our choice. But we should remember– the Mass does not belong to us. By Canon Law laymen have no say in anything in the Church– except they can try to influence Church leaders.
After Vatican II the first time that I ever heard Gregorian Chant sung in English was at a Vespers service at a huge, beautiful monastery, I had to do all I could to stifle laughter. It was to me preposterous. (About 15 years later this large, beautiful monastery was finally closed and sold to real estate developers.) Thousands of men and women in religious orders greatly disliked the Vatican II changes to their orders and to their Mass and Divine Office. Pretty soon these religious orders saw thousands of exits of consecrated men and women. And a great many of these orders closed forever. After Vatican II an estimated 70,000-100,000 men left the priesthood worldwide. An estimated 18,000 men left the priesthood in the U.S. Their priestly vocations weren’t worth it to them anymore. One of the first things we were told in church at the close of Vatican II was that now a big priest shortage was predicted. Nothing we could do about it. Nothing much you can do about anything in the Catholic Church. It has always been that way.
The part of the Mass that first sounded disrespectful to me is the very ending where the priest says, “The Mass is ended”, or “the Mass is ended, go in peace,” and we reply, “Thanks be to God.” It first sounded to my hears that we were thanking God that it is all over. Hopefully the intention is to thank God for letting us have a Mass. It is in the Traditional Latin Mass, Ordinary Latin Mass and all the English-speaking Masses.
Correction: sounded to my “ears”, not “hears”.